Episode XIX | Mafia/Witch Win

[xUltiix]

Stances so far
Spoiler: UzayAltay - Null Town
Phone0Ix - Null
heytheregirl17 - Null
Chemist1422 - Null
GrumpyGoomba - Null Scum
ryanyb - Null Town
watchme1 - Lock Town
Google - Null Scum
MichaelgRook - Null
MrChuckleteeth - Null
TheWabbit - Null Town
EvilDeanius0 - Null
roz1roz - Null
xUltiix - Null Scum
parkerparkour - Null
Jalandh - Null
HarperReed - Null Scum
Cenvil2 - Null
ladd - Null Town

Not enough to go from but it's something.

These reads are e l b i g g a r b o and not because you scumread me
Where did they come from?

This is where I first pointed it out

Stances so far
Spoiler: UzayAltay - Null Town
Phone0Ix - Null
heytheregirl17 - Null
Chemist1422 - Null
GrumpyGoomba - Null Scum
ryanyb - Null Town
watchme1 - Lock Town
Google - Null Scum
MichaelgRook - Null
MrChuckleteeth - Null
TheWabbit - Null Town
EvilDeanius0 - Null
roz1roz - Null
xUltiix - Null Scum
parkerparkour - Null
Jalandh - Null
HarperReed - Null Scum
Cenvil2 - Null
ladd - Null Town

Not enough to go from but it's something.

NT - Uzay, ryan, wabbit, ladd
NS - Goomba, Google, Harper, Ultiix

These feel kinda sheepy, except Uzay and sort of Ultiix

Can you explain those two?

Uzay's tone coming into the thread felt like it came from a towny perspective and is questioning things that are happening leading me to think it comes from a town mindset.

Ultiix, I didn't like their entrance, didn't sit well with me

these reads are hot garbage
basically stemming from everyone having some sort of null
makes it look like there's zero hierarchy or intensity in your reads

Well everyone starts out as a null read and I build on from there. Also it was only 24 hours so obviously I'm going to be very inconclusive about my reads, but like I said its a start. Aye better hot garbage than hot trash amirite

watchme's reads are somewhat concerning to me

how are uzay and wabbit the only town so far to you and how do goomba, ultii, and harper feel like scum to you

I had ladd and ryan as well? Goomba hasn't said anything productive, Ultii already explained, Harper's gut scum

These explanations are unsatisfactory, it’s all reads that are easy to ditch at any time and things that can’t be “checked” if that makes sense because to ditch one of these reads all you have to do is say you don’t feel the gutread anymore
I generally see a lot of people do that as scum and sometimes I even do as scum
They are also as mentioned by wabbit sheepy and already kind of uncontroversial reads

[roz1roz]

I disagree with pretty much each of Wabbit's post about how you should play mafia on this page.

[watchme1]

/vote watchme1
This is currently my strongest scumread; reads are mostly terrible in a seeming-fabricated way, and they still haven’t provided content.
If anyone has questions about this read feel free to ask

What seems fabricated about watchme's reads?

Asking for a friend called gut.

I pointed this out earlier and I think others did too but I’ll quote it forward

Yea nah I'm calling bs on that, do you believe my reads were fabricated cause I didn't really give a whole lot of reason on them? Most of them were just general stances from my pov and I believe chem asked about them and I gave reason to them. Or did you just not like the one read I gave on you?

[TheWabbit]

I disagree with pretty much each of Wabbit's post about how you should play mafia on this page.

Why should town force to build that they're town?
I think that town naturally reveals themselves as town.

[TheWabbit]

Also remind me to update my signature.

update sig or die

[watchme1]

- snip -
These explanations are unsatisfactory, it’s all reads that are easy to ditch at any time and things that can’t be “checked” if that makes sense because to ditch one of these reads all you have to do is say you don’t feel the gutread anymore
I generally see a lot of people do that as scum and sometimes I even do as scum
They are also as mentioned by wabbit sheepy and already kind of uncontroversial reads

Yea I guess I'll say harper's town now cause gut

My read on goomba being uncontributive was true at the time, none of their posts helped at all

[TheWabbit]

you can't place the words elusive/harper and town in the same sentence without backing it with sufficient proof

[roz1roz]

I disagree with pretty much each of Wabbit's post about how you should play mafia on this page.

Why should town force to build that they're town?
I think that town naturally reveals themselves as town.

Yeah, I know, American mafia school.
Even I'm playing it for this game, even tho I dislike it.

Russian school is in my opinion way more exciting, but also way riskier, hence for it many players actually try to fake confirm self as town when town.
Yes, fake townslips as a town are a thing there.

[xUltiix]

/vote watchme1
This is currently my strongest scumread; reads are mostly terrible in a seeming-fabricated way, and they still haven’t provided content.
If anyone has questions about this read feel free to ask

What seems fabricated about watchme's reads?

Asking for a friend called gut.

I pointed this out earlier and I think others did too but I’ll quote it forward

Yea nah I'm calling bs on that, do you believe my reads were fabricated cause I didn't really give a whole lot of reason on them? Most of them were just general stances from my pov and I believe chem asked about them and I gave reason to them. Or did you just not like the one read I gave on you?

Why would I not like the one read you gave on me? I’m not afraid of being scumread.
This feels like a terrible deflection attempt and also very convenient you dont post shit until someone scumreads you

[xUltiix]

Note also: part of the watchme read is a gut read, in addition to the other stuff

[TheWabbit]

so everyone FPSes. cool.

[TheWabbit]

so everyone FPSes. cool.

this is hypocritical of me but yes

[watchme1]

/vote watchme1
This is currently my strongest scumread; reads are mostly terrible in a seeming-fabricated way, and they still haven’t provided content.
If anyone has questions about this read feel free to ask

What seems fabricated about watchme's reads?

Asking for a friend called gut.

I pointed this out earlier and I think others did too but I’ll quote it forward

Yea nah I'm calling bs on that, do you believe my reads were fabricated cause I didn't really give a whole lot of reason on them? Most of them were just general stances from my pov and I believe chem asked about them and I gave reason to them. Or did you just not like the one read I gave on you?

Why would I not like the one read you gave on me? I’m not afraid of being scumread.
This feels like a terrible deflection attempt and also very convenient you dont post shit until someone scumreads you

I posted stuff before I even got sr'd what are oyu talking about. The last sentence was more of an afterthought if anything

[watchme1]

so everyone FPSes. cool.

first person shooter?

[xUltiix]

Hot take - One of said towncore or two is scum, no way town core is ever 100% pure d1

This post right here is also just pure shade with no valuable contribution, also is a way to make it look like you’re making town gamestate-furthering content while actually not (there’s an extreme lack of that in watchmes iso also)

[TheWabbit]

fancy play syndrome

[xUltiix]

/vote watchme1
This is currently my strongest scumread; reads are mostly terrible in a seeming-fabricated way, and they still haven’t provided content.
If anyone has questions about this read feel free to ask

What seems fabricated about watchme's reads?

Asking for a friend called gut.

I pointed this out earlier and I think others did too but I’ll quote it forward

Yea nah I'm calling bs on that, do you believe my reads were fabricated cause I didn't really give a whole lot of reason on them? Most of them were just general stances from my pov and I believe chem asked about them and I gave reason to them. Or did you just not like the one read I gave on you?

Why would I not like the one read you gave on me? I’m not afraid of being scumread.
This feels like a terrible deflection attempt and also very convenient you dont post shit until someone scumreads you

I posted stuff before I even got sr'd what are oyu talking about. The last sentence was more of an afterthought if anything

It’s not a main focus of the read, just something that annoys me whatever alignment they are. I just hand stern posts especially contentful ones in a while from you before this

[TheWabbit]

jalandh talk to me uwu

[roz1roz]

so everyone FPSes. cool.

Not only FPSes, also load of gambits and trying to put scum in an uncomfortable position, also way less actual reading, to a point some players don't need it, cause they have other ways to help the game state.

And American mafia is about scumhunting and being clear about your intentions.

That's a discussion for other time tho.

[watchme1]

Hot take - One of said towncore or two is scum, no way town core is ever 100% pure d1

This post right here is also just pure shade with no valuable contribution, also is a way to make it look like you’re making town gamestate-furthering content while actually not (there’s an extreme lack of that in watchmes iso also)

So you're saying I'm saying useless shit, but also saying there's an extreme lack of that (useless shit) in my iso. Nice

[TheWabbit]

so everyone FPSes. cool.

Not only FPSes, also load of gambits and trying to put scum in an uncomfortable position, also way less actual reading, to a point some players don't need it, cause they have other ways to help the game state.

And American mafia is about scumhunting and being clear about your intentions.

That's a discussion for other time tho.

I'd love to see a hybrid of both concepts in action.

[Chemist1422]

Ultiix's case on watchme makes me feel better about him (ultiix, not watchme, before one of you spoons asks)

[MichaelgRook]

I have TvT feelings on ultii v watchme

I promis3 I'll finalu sleepn now

[TheWabbit]

on the gray for watchme atm but i agree with xultiix bring villa

[HarperReed]

Why does chemist have that many votes already?
That's rather interesting

Watchme hasn’t moved his RVS vote
Phone thought I “scumslipped”
Michael randomly sheeped Phone

How does one scum slip on d1? That seems like a thonker

/vote Elusive
This is fake
When their buddy slipped Day 1 at 18E there is no way town!Elusive discreditting with using A bad argument Like that

Harper would like to think that everyone here would know the difference between that game and this one that makes it significantly less likely to have such a slip.
Argument denied