Town of Salem Game Forums

Will share chat whenI become sure We didnt write anything wrong .

https://discord.gg/FrzcbsD

Maf chat + nearly empty scum mentor chats

Qvapil wrote:

Phone0Ix wrote:Rick was my mentor

We were tracking mamaniejebanana the night we died :/

Wish I caught your softs and decided to heal you but me and era agreed to play it safe and just heal a townread instead

I only softed once (as far as I know) and that was by accident, so it weren't rlly softs more like a slip

Also me and Rick townread htg so much because we thought they were the doctor

Just since this is a mentor game and for the sake of learning I'd like to say why banana never should have been townread in the first place.
When it comes to new players playing town/scum, they're playstyle will be very predictable even without meta.
It essentially fits into two categories:
1. Town, in which the new player makes bad reads confidently and sounds unreasonable, but is opinionated nonetheless.
2. Mafia, in which the new player tries to sound reasonable, and often makes weaker statements like "idk this could be scum, but maybe they could be town as well..."
This is what the term noob town/noob scum *actually* means.

If you actually read banana's posts, almost all of them fell into the second category. There was really no reason anyone should have been townreading banana.

My mentee listening to pretty much none of my advice was also pretty cool.

S0me0ne23 wrote:Just since this is a mentor game and for the sake of learning I'd like to say why banana never should have been townread in the first place.
When it comes to new players playing town/scum, they're playstyle will be very predictable even without meta.
It essentially fits into two categories:
1. Town, in which the new player makes bad reads confidently and sounds unreasonable, but is opinionated nonetheless.
2. Mafia, in which the new player tries to sound reasonable, and often makes weaker statements like "idk this could be scum, but maybe they could be town as well..."
This is what the term noob town/noob scum *actually* means.

If you actually read banana's posts, almost all of them fell into the second category. There was really no reason anyone should have been townreading banana.

that makes tons of sense actually, thx for pointing it out!

UzayAltay wrote:Will share chat whenI become sure We didnt write anything wrong .

I didnt reread it but you can share i think

S0me0ne23 wrote:Just since this is a mentor game and for the sake of learning I'd like to say why banana never should have been townread in the first place.
When it comes to new players playing town/scum, they're playstyle will be very predictable even without meta.
It essentially fits into two categories:
1. Town, in which the new player makes bad reads confidently and sounds unreasonable, but is opinionated nonetheless.
2. Mafia, in which the new player tries to sound reasonable, and often makes weaker statements like "idk this could be scum, but maybe they could be town as well..."
This is what the term noob town/noob scum *actually* means.

If you actually read banana's posts, almost all of them fell into the second category. There was really no reason anyone should have been townreading banana.

Pfffffft, so true
It was so hard to work around it, especially at the beginning
and it seems we didn't manage to get rid of it completely

ejjinami wrote:

S0me0ne23 wrote:Just since this is a mentor game and for the sake of learning I'd like to say why banana never should have been townread in the first place.
When it comes to new players playing town/scum, they're playstyle will be very predictable even without meta.
It essentially fits into two categories:
1. Town, in which the new player makes bad reads confidently and sounds unreasonable, but is opinionated nonetheless.
2. Mafia, in which the new player tries to sound reasonable, and often makes weaker statements like "idk this could be scum, but maybe they could be town as well..."
This is what the term noob town/noob scum *actually* means.

If you actually read banana's posts, almost all of them fell into the second category. There was really no reason anyone should have been townreading banana.

Pfffffft, so true
It was so hard to work around it, especially at the beginning
and it seems we didn't manage to get rid of it completely

Banana's play was good, especially for a beginner, it's just kind of matter-of-fact that a first wolf game will be like that.

S0me0ne23 wrote:Just since this is a mentor game and for the sake of learning I'd like to say why banana never should have been townread in the first place.
When it comes to new players playing town/scum, they're playstyle will be very predictable even without meta.
It essentially fits into two categories:
1. Town, in which the new player makes bad reads confidently and sounds unreasonable, but is opinionated nonetheless.
2. Mafia, in which the new player tries to sound reasonable, and often makes weaker statements like "idk this could be scum, but maybe they could be town as well..."
This is what the term noob town/noob scum *actually* means.

If you actually read banana's posts, almost all of them fell into the second category. There was really no reason anyone should have been townreading banana.

Well, hindsight being 20/20, I was always PoEing Mama into my Mafia bracket, and I was constantly asking Phone to challenge the town read on my behalf, but he was reluctant due to the strength of his TR.

In our defense, if we weren't attacked, we would have caught him.

Is Phone's slip the reason we died?

we didnt notice the slip

TheDebil wrote:we didnt notice the slip

Why attack us, then? Phone is pretty obvious Town to me when I play, but everyone else loves mislynching him. You didn't think you would manage that this game?

rick, can you send mentor chat?

dota2reporter wrote:rick, can you send mentor chat?

Sure, I told Chemist I was ok with it

https://discord.gg/N3cFXgT

Rickdaily12 wrote:

TheDebil wrote:we didnt notice the slip

Why attack us, then? Phone is pretty obvious Town to me when I play, but everyone else loves mislynching him. You didn't think you would manage that this game?

phone may be a mislynch but he had strong competition in retral/google
our main targets for kill were qva/phone,since we thought they both had the highest chances to be pr
we ended up going for phone since he was less obvious of a doctor heal

TheDebil wrote:

Rickdaily12 wrote:

TheDebil wrote:we didnt notice the slip

Why attack us, then? Phone is pretty obvious Town to me when I play, but everyone else loves mislynching him. You didn't think you would manage that this game?

phone may be a mislynch but he had strong competition in retral/google
our main targets for kill were qva/phone,since we thought they both had the highest chances to be pr
we ended up going for phone since he was less obvious of a doctor heal

Yeah, basically that. I was fine with anyone as long as they were townie and in my PR poe...
There wasn't much to it

modrant tmrw

Chemist1422 wrote:modrant tmrw

wow you're actually making one?

TheWabbit wrote:

Chemist1422 wrote:modrant tmrw

wow you're actually making one?

he has been all this time

smug waitin

Chemist1422 wrote:modrant tmrw

hmmm

dota2reporter wrote:

Chemist1422 wrote:modrant tmrw

hmmm

well then 54 happened so

right

understandable