chuckle (hyena) eragon multi jamez (seth) heli (uzay)
Chuckle was good. Did not expect him being a traitor. I would have shot Eragon (90% or more), if I get lynched btw. His tunnel on me was awful obvious. (literally questioning my fair points, and skipping important posts in their walls) Also Town was unlucky to have the scummiest villagers...
Now , Let's speak More. TBH I never considered There is 5 traitor , I thought it is 4 at most . Eragon , TBH I Dont scumhunt More after I realize Multi is traitor probably , Like I didnt read This long walls, too ( Except The things about me ) , If I thought , still seems hard but Maybe due Him townreading me easily , Given that at A low-activity Game he know I can easily blend in , especially at A Game allies are not known. Chuckle , Weird thing was he was Also TRing me with thinking I am scum , I wasnt caring who stay alive as More as I keep lynch my PoE , but I Dont think I Will be able to find them , Unless for reason I scumread them/decide to pressure them and they reacted bad.
About town , reads can be bad , I wont blame anybody for their reads as I didnt play at that game as town. But they should try More Than lynching Scummy players ,until they lose or think they lynched enough traitors ; for example as town . For example : " Name your top 4 TR . " Or " assume You are lynched today , write 3 venge-target ( ignore You can only venge The players vote You ) "
I did expect Town to do a little better than they did, but yeah, the wolves played so well this game that I don't think someone like say, Chuckle being a Cynic with 4 traitors would even have mattered.
The nice part is that, if ever ran again, the next mod could choose completely different specifications to the game and it would be run again without anything other than speculation as to when a loss would happen.
I think the consensus among the Mafia is that knowing 4 Town helped them way more than hurt them, and did nothing to TMI what they knew.
Could just be because we need a new Town meta for this game, though.
"Don't lie this is all so you could post Ace Attorney gifs and have it be relevant isn't it." ~Sarah Thorpe
dota2reporter wrote:chuckle you should count this as a win tho
I really don't know what to tell you. From a hindsight perspective, yes, undoubtedly regardless of what I did, this would 95% of the time be a win for me.
But from my perspective at the time of my replacement, I felt like I could have lost mafia the game if, say, I was the only traitor left, or if there was 1 other traitor left.
dota2reporter wrote:crazy idea: traitors have 4 townclears but cynics have 1 townclear too
Then each person would just post their townclear and if any overlap you'd find a cynic.
that can be a traitor too tho
Yeah and how would the traitors know who is a traitor and who isn't?
Everyone knows at least 1 townmember. Given traitors are outnumbered because of balance, posting that at the start of the game turns the game into a PoE hunt for traitors.