I understand why the gamethrowing rules are extremely forgiving, because there are a lot of valid ways to play the game. However, seeing players purposefully skirt around this line, I feel like there should be some kind of warning against such play. Not with threat of ban, but rather threat of not being able to play in ranked.
For example, there's a player that just does nothing every game unless they are town -- and if they're town they just say their role once on the stand, no will, nothing else, no matter why they are being put on the stand. It has absolutely ruined multiple games but isn't considered gamethrowing, I don't think. There was another player that refused to post a will because they thought that wills ruined the spirit of the game (and didn't keep one when they died) -- I mean okay, but what are you doing in ranked? Could players like these get some slap on the wrist, like having to play another 10 games in ranked practice before they can play ranked again (or some variable number of games up to judge's discretion)?
I think this would be a better system than a permanent strike on your record and would allow punishments that fit the crime. Thoughts?