itaicool wrote:I don't think exe should depend on there being an evil majority to win, they should be able to cause mislynch and doubt even if there is town majority but its impossible once the veteran is confirmed via townie dying to them in alert, the same reason mayor and jailor can't be targets I believe veteran has the same issue.
itaicool wrote:I don't think exe should depend on there being an evil majority to win, they should be able to cause mislynch and doubt even if there is town majority but its impossible once the veteran is confirmed via townie dying to them in alert, the same reason mayor and jailor can't be targets I believe veteran has the same issue.
Yemac wrote:That won't work because almost any role can confirm themselves. Medium, Escort, Retri, Transporter, Vet, Vigi, Doctor, BG. Only TI's can't be 100% confirmed (except maybe LO). I would say suggest something that would make it easier for exe. Like a "give up" button that turns you into a jester. Say your target is Escort and they get confirmed n1, you can turn yourself into a jester (Only at night) and then hope to get voted.
syjfwbaobfwl wrote:Yemac wrote:That won't work because almost any role can confirm themselves. Medium, Escort, Retri, Transporter, Vet, Vigi, Doctor, BG. Only TI's can't be 100% confirmed (except maybe LO). I would say suggest something that would make it easier for exe. Like a "give up" button that turns you into a jester. Say your target is Escort and they get confirmed n1, you can turn yourself into a jester (Only at night) and then hope to get voted.
then the role of executioner is pointless, everyone would give up d1 to become jester because win as jester is very easy
kyuss420 wrote:syjfwbaobfwl wrote:Yemac wrote:That won't work because almost any role can confirm themselves. Medium, Escort, Retri, Transporter, Vet, Vigi, Doctor, BG. Only TI's can't be 100% confirmed (except maybe LO). I would say suggest something that would make it easier for exe. Like a "give up" button that turns you into a jester. Say your target is Escort and they get confirmed n1, you can turn yourself into a jester (Only at night) and then hope to get voted.
then the role of executioner is pointless, everyone would give up d1 to become jester because win as jester is very easy
yup, you can set yourself up for a lynch, and have death immunity until town is ready to vote...
Joacgroso wrote:I feel like I went from Light Yagami to Keiichi Maebara.
Yemac wrote:kyuss420 wrote:syjfwbaobfwl wrote:Yemac wrote:That won't work because almost any role can confirm themselves. Medium, Escort, Retri, Transporter, Vet, Vigi, Doctor, BG. Only TI's can't be 100% confirmed (except maybe LO). I would say suggest something that would make it easier for exe. Like a "give up" button that turns you into a jester. Say your target is Escort and they get confirmed n1, you can turn yourself into a jester (Only at night) and then hope to get voted.
then the role of executioner is pointless, everyone would give up d1 to become jester because win as jester is very easy
yup, you can set yourself up for a lynch, and have death immunity until town is ready to vote...
What would you all suggest then for exe? Exe has a problem with being confirmed easily and confirming town. You say 12 is sus, you get hanged. boom, 12 gets confirmed mafia has a that's much harder time to win.
SilverCruz wrote:This isn't exclusive to Veteran. Spy posts and nobody contradicts them, Town will get you first if you push them anyway, and doing something like saying "Their will is bogus, I'm Lookout, I watched <someone they saw the Mafia visit>, and there were no visitors except for me", well they claimed first so the Town's more likely to take their word than yours.
Likewise, Sheriff calls and nails a Mafia, then you have no way of getting rid of them through misdirection, you can only hope that the Mafia knocks them off sooner rather than later and play into that.
Part of the problem is there being a static Executioner, if you ask me. Too predictable. It should at least be changed so that it can be either an Executioner or Jester from go. If you're bent on there never being a second Witch then adding a Neutral Ex/Je bracket and using that instead of Executioner would make that work, though I'd say the possibility of a second Witch would be probably be better since it'd give the Hypnotist a way to disrupt information that doesn't exist in the current Un/Ranked role list, ignoring Hypnotist's existing problem with exposing itself through conflicting feedback.
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 13 guests