New Achievements, and Lots of them.

[ABadWord]

The Town

Bodyguard:
-It's my Job
Defend a Revealed Mayor.
-Very Efficient
Defend someone before night four.

Escort:
-Long Term
Role block one player three nights in a row.
-Peaceful Night
Role block a Mafioso or Godfather that is attempting to attack.

Investigator:
-Well That's Suspicious
Investigate someone with framer results.
-On The Ball
Hang someone you investigated the night before that was evil.
(note: "evil" means any non-Town role)

Lookout:
-Unsettling Sight
Watch someone who died that night.
-Neighborhood Watch
Watch a Revealed Mayor.

Mayor:
-A True Leader
Win a game having never voted guilty on a Town member.
-Making a difference
As a revealed Mayor, have your vote be the deciding factor in a player being hanged.
-Long Running Campaign
Reveal as Mayor when there are five or less players left alive.

Medium:
-Restless Night
Have eight people in the graveyard while you are alive.
-Whisper to Power
Seance a Jailor or Mayor.

Retributionist:
-So Much Death, So Many Choices
Resurrect five Town members.
-I am The Law
Resurrect a Vigilante and shoot an evil role.

Sheriff:
-Town of Scum
Find three people suspicious in one game.
-Trust your Hunch
Find two people suspicious two nights in a row.

Spy:
-Outnumbered!
See six Mafia/Coven members visit people in one night. (Coven All Any exclusive achievement unless you get like three amnesiacs together)
-Checking up
Bug a Revealed Mayor.
-TMI
Have a bugged player have three interactions in one night.

Transporter:
-Confusing isn't it?
Transport someone a Consiglier is investigating.
-Missed me!
Swap yourself with an evil role the night you are attacked.

Vampire Hunter:
-Job Well Done
Successfully kill all vampires and become a Vigilante, then shoot an evil role.
(note: unsure on how this would wonk on a programming level, might be unable to be implemented, sorry )
-Righteous Cause
Kill all Vampires before day five.

Veteran:
-No Time for Fun
Shoot a Consort.
-Been Through a Lot
Be attacked and live on two separate alerts.

Vigilante:
-Duel Me!
Kill an evil the night they kill you.
-Close Enough
Kill an Amnesiac, Survivor, Guardian Angel, or Jester.

Crusader:
-Loyal Knight
Defend one person three nights in a row.
-Holy Crusade
Win a game without killing any town members.

Tracker:
-Trail ran Cold
Track someone using an atrial visit
-Didn't Need to see This
Track someone as they kill someone else.

Trapper:
-New Rug
Trap a Werewolf.
-XL Trap
Have a trap be triggered by three people.
-So Much for Preparation.
Have a trap kill someone the night you place it.

Psychic:
-The Sight Knows all
After getting a vision of evil, hang a evil the next day.
-Wonder What he is
See a Revealed Mayor in your visions.

The Mafia

Blackmailer:
-You Know to Much Friend
Blackmail a Town Investigative role.
-Cut out The Tongue
Blackmail a Jailor or Mayor

Consiglier:
-Can't Hide From us
Find a Mayor before he Reveals.
-Keep Tabs on Them
Find any Neutral Killer.
-The Man In Charge
Find a Jailor.

Consort:
-Execution Rescheduled
Role block a Jailor about to execute a player.
-Law can wait
Role Block a Vigilante about to attack a player.

Disguiser:
-Am I Special?
Disguise yourself as a unique role.
-Not as Useful
Disguise as an evil role.

Forger:
-Novelist
Forge a will that has 50 or more characters in it.
-Fake News
Forge a Town Investigative roles will.

Framer:
-Tricky
Frame someone that was investigated by a Sheriff or Investigator in the same night.
-The Fall Guy
Hang the person you framed last night.

Godfather:
-So much for Clean Hands
Kill four people in one game
-I run This Town
Kill a Mayor

Janitor:
-Spotless
Clean three people.
-Overtime
Clean someone not killed by the Mafia.
-What They Don't Know Won't Hurt Them
Clean a Town Investigative role.
-Such Secrets
Clean an unrevealed Mayor.

Mafioso:
-Ordered Around
Kill someone you didn't vote for.
-Menace of the Streets
Kill five players in one game.
-The Don Sends his Regards
Kill a Jailor or Mayor.

Hypnotist:
-What is Real Anymore
Hypnotize someone three times in one game.
-We Saved You
Hypnotize someone into thinking they where attacked and healed.

Ambusher:
-Guerrilla Tactics
Ambush two people.
-Nosey Nosey
Ambush a Lookout.

Benign

Amnesiac:
-I made up my Mind
Pick a role night two.
-How did I Forget That?
Remember you where a Werewolf, Vampire, or Pestilence.
-Now I'm the Big Shot!
Remember a unique role.

Survivor:
-True Neutral
Win without voting guilty once.
-Ah yes. "Neutral"
Vote to hang three players.
-Be Gentle
Win with Pestilence
-Help the Little Guys
Win without Town, Mafia, Vampires, or Coven winning.
-Lucky to be Alive
Win a game where four or more people died in one night.

Guardian Angle:
-A True Angle
Win while dead.
-Boss Mans Gonna be Mad
Win after your target dies.

Neutral Evils:
Witch:
-So There They are
Control a Mafia member
-The Start of a Coven
Witch a Witch.

Executioner:
-Pointless Life
Have your target die before you can hang them. Then win as a Jester.
-You Guys Seem Cool
Win with the Town.

Jester:
-World Most Suspicious Clown
Be hanged day two.
-Now Here's a Good Joke
Kill a Jailor or Mayor.
-My Memoirs
Win with a full will.
(note: this ones silly, but I really like it for no reason.)
-FINALLY!
Be hanged on day seven or later.
-Lady Luck is my Mistress
Pick no target for your haunt.
-You Can't Escape Guilt
Haunt someone who was transported or jailed.
-Worst Straight man
Haunt Pestilence. (dangit)

Neutral Killing

Arsonist:
-Lets Talk
Ignite and kill everyone but yourself and one other person.
-A Fellow Firebug
Win with another Arsonist.
(they don't need to live, just win)
-Moths, all of Them
Douse three people in one night.

Serial Killer:
-Bit of the ol' In Out?
Kill more them one person in one night.
-Couldn't be me
Don't kill someone who role blocked you.
-Can Never be to Careful
Be cautious while dead.
(note: please don't remove that, it makes me smile)

Werewolf:
-Is this how Moons Work?
Attack three nights in a row.
-Reverse Guard Dog
Kill someone protecting another player.

Juggernaut:
-Awwww
Have your fist attack in a game fail to kill.
-Do you Know who I am?
Be attacked and live, then kill your attacker.

The Coven:

Coven Leader:
-Your use is Over
Drain a player after having them kill someone.
-Not Your Everyday Hag
Survive an attack using your basic defense.

Potion Master:
-You can't Handle my Potions!
Kill four people in one game.
-I Know All!
Reveal the roles of four people.

Hex Master:
-Level Nine Spell Slot
Use the Final Hex
-Magic Missile
Kill a player being protected by someone using your astral attack.

Medusa:
-Eye for an Eye
Turn someone who killed you to stone.
-Once a Beauty Always a Beauty
Have two different gazes turn people to stone in one game.

Necromancer:
-Wish You Where Still Here
Resurrect a Coven Member
-Rival Gang
Resurrect a Mafia Member
-The Dead Walk the Earth!
Resurrect five people in one game.

Poisoner:
-My Poison has no Cure
Have someone die to your poison even after they are healed.
-I feel Cheated
Have three different targets healed of your poison.

CHAOS

Vampire:
-No More Room in the Coffins
Be a Vampire after a Town member is killed by Vampires.
-So Thirsty
Have two bite attempts fail in a row.
-Free Loader
Win after being converted.

Plaguebearer and Pestilence:
-Coughing Fit
Have five new people infected in one night.
-Quarantined
Fail to infect someone due to them being Jailed.
-That Tickled
Be hit with an Unstoppable attack and live.

Pirate:
-Swashed and Buckled
Kill a Serial Killer
-That be a Rip-off!
Win a duel and still die.

General
-Scroll Scholar
Equip three different scrolls.
-Read the Scroll
Use a scroll and win the same game.
-Creative
Name yourself "Bob".
(secret achievement shhhhh)
-Now I'm Confused
Name yourself after any role.
-Just Like the Real Salem
Be in a game where ten or more players did not submit a custom name.
-Doing Better then Most
Win five games in a row.
-Competitive
Win fifty Ranked/Coven Ranked games.
-Casual
Win fifty Classic/Coven Classic games.
-Chaotic
Win fifty All Any/Coven All Any games.
-Star Crossed Lovers
In 'Lovers', win with a Lover of a different faction.
-Through the Storm is a Rainbow
In 'Rainbow Mode', win as a Survivor.
-I Vant Your Blood!
Win 'Dracula's Castle' as one of the starting Vampires without dying.
-Very Important Murder
In 'VIP', kill the VIP.
(note: you don't have to be an evil, but you really should be. If a CL has someone kill the VIP both her and her target will get this achievement)
-Bad to the Bone
In 'Town Traitor' or 'Coven Town Traitor', win as the traitor.

[PatrykSzczescie]

Achievs look great, just some numbers need to be adjusted, mostly to be more difficult.

Also, there's an issue if achievs appearing during the game, giving you some information you're not supposed to have, for example as trans you will be aware for the first time when consig visits one of your targets.

[Robbytherobot]

I second this, I love achievements.

[TheFluffyWaffleV2]

WAIT SO I'M NOT THE ONLY ONE THAT HAS MADE A LIST OF A HARD ACHIEVEMENT FOR EVER ROLE?

Bodyguard:
-Self Defense
Attack someone who attacked you.

Doctor:
-Want Some Water?
Attempt to heal someone incinerated by an Arsonist.

Escort:
-This Seems Dangerous
Role block a cautious Serial Killer.

Investigator:
-Seeing A Pattern
Get the same results 3 times in a row from different people.

Jailor:
-Do Not Collect $200
Jail a revealed Mayor.

Lookout:
-Poor Guy
Watch 2 people attack your target in the same night.

Mayor:
-Leader of Nothing
While revealed, be the last player alive.

Medium:
-Curses!
Die on the first night.

Retributionist:
-Grave Digger
Resurrect 6 players in a game.

Sheriff:
-See No Evil
Find 5 people innocent in a row.

Spy:
-Didn't Want To Hear That
See your bug target get role blocked.

Transporter:
-I'm Helping!
Have both of your targets die on the same night.

Vampire Hunter:
-That's It?
Become a Vigilante on the second day.

Veteran:
-Awareness
Kill at least 1 person with all 3 of your alerts.

Vigilante:
-Jumped the Gun
Shoot someone on the first night.

Crusader:
-Miscommunication
Kill and be killed by another Crusader.

Psychic:
-That's Not Good
Be unable to find any good in your vision.

Tracker:
-Gross
Watch an Escort or Consort role block someone.

Trapper:
-Payback
Kill the person who killed you with your trap.



Blackmailer:
-Think About It
Blackmail a Vigilante after they shoot a town member.

Consiglier:
-Twins
Get the same role from 2 different people in a row.

Consort:
-Forget About Them (your name is better)
Role block a Jailor about to execute a player. (we had the same idea)

Disguiser:
-Gotta Believe Me
Die while disguised as a unique role. (same again)

Forger:
-Ms. Information
Forge 3 Town Investigative wills in a game.

Framer:
-Jump To Conclusions
Have the target you framed on the first night be lynched on the second day.

Godfather:
-Manipulative
While the Jailor has the ability to execute, survive being jailed after on the third night or later.

Janitor:
-Pretty Funny
Clean a Jester.

Mafioso:
-Sorry Boss
Be role blocked, forcing your Godfather to attack.

Hypnotist:
-Aggressive Reaction
Hypnotize a Serial Killer into thinking they were role blocked.

Ambusher:
-Go Go Go!
Prepare an ambush on a target 3 other Mafia members are visiting.



Amnesiac:
-What Was I Doing?
Be role blocked on the night you remembered a role.

Survivor:
-True Neutral
Win without voting. (damn almost the same thing)
also I love "Be Gentle"

Guardian Angle:
-Thank God
Have your target be acquitted.

Witch:
-Uh... Sorry?
Witch the Godfather into a Mafia member.

Executioner:
-Silver Tongue
Have your target lynched while they are a unique Town role.

Jester:
-Delayed Masochism
Be lynched on day seven or later.



Arsonist:
-Warm Up
Ignite on the first night, and kill someone.

Serial Killer:
-Killing Spree
Kill 2 people in the same night.

Werewolf:
-Old Rivalry
Attack a Vampire who visited your target.

Juggernaut:
-Oh, Come On!
Die on the first night. (Only possible by Pirate).



Coven Leader:
-Guardian Devil
Force a Guardian Angel to protect their target.

Potion Master:
-Not Bad: Reveal a Consigliere.

Hex Master:
-One From All
Kill a member from every faction, except Coven, with your final hex.

Medusa:
-Unsolvable Case
Be killed and be cleaned by a Janitor while stone gazing.

Necromancer:
-Toy Soldiers
Resurrect a total of 4 Vigilantes or Mafiosos combined in the same game.

Poisoner:
-No Antidote
Poison and kill a Doctor



Vampire:
-Old Rivals
While the Vampires have majority in a game, lynch a Werewolf.

Plaguebearer and Pestilence:
-Volatile Infection
Have 6 people be infected in a single night

Pirate:
-Duel of the Gods
Duel Pestilence.


I like some of yours better, tho

[Ezradekezra]

Investigator:
-On The Ball
Hang someone you investigated the night before that was evil.
(note: "evil" means any non-Town role)

I'd change this so that "Evil" doesn't include Neutral Benign roles, as they count as good for the purposes of Psychic visions.

I do feel like a few ToS role could use more achievements, though.
/support

[kyuss420]

I thought you guys said hard achievements?

These all seem too easy

[TheFluffyWaffleV2]

I thought you guys said hard achievements?

These all seem too easy

mine are (mostly) hard luck wise
not skill wise obviously

[KAKERMAN23]

a true angle

[ABadWord]

I feel a balance of "easy" and "hard achievements is good for the game.
If most are "but you have heard of me"- lose ten duels in one game as Pirate we'd all have like 7 achievements. But if they all where "who are you"- Investigate someone as Investigator, then they would mean squat.
I just want more achievements, especially for some of the less fortunate roles like Blackmailer. Poor man has 2 of his 3 achievements being screwed by transporter.

Also to the concerns that these would give information, yes, however we already have a few that do that such as "Gotcha", and the Medium achievements. The Devs stated they where looking into having the Achivements show up at the end of a game instead of right as it happens, so that shouldn't be an issue.

(also, really like FluffyWaffles ones. Especially "That's Not Good".)

[Robbytherobot]

I would LOVE more achievements

[BisonPuncher]

I'd love this. I love getting achievements but have most of them already.

[kyuss420]

I feel a balance of "easy" and "hard achievements is good for the game.
If most are "but you have heard of me"- lose ten duels in one game as Pirate we'd all have like 7 achievements. But if they all where "who are you"- Investigate someone as Investigator, then they would mean squat.
I just want more achievements, especially for some of the less fortunate roles like Blackmailer. Poor man has 2 of his 3 achievements being screwed by transporter.

Also to the concerns that these would give information, yes, however we already have a few that do that such as "Gotcha", and the Medium achievements. The Devs stated they where looking into having the Achivements show up at the end of a game instead of right as it happens, so that shouldn't be an issue.

(also, really like FluffyWaffles ones. Especially "That's Not Good".)

only 7? Id beg to differ
https://imgur.com/6GYoZ4H

[Ezradekezra]

I'm gonna use this thread to post my own achievement ideas without clogging up the forums.

Crusader
Religious War
Kill the Crusader that killed you

Escort
Consent
Roleblock the person that roleblocked you

Medium
Guide to the Afterlife
Seance someone who died the same night

Psychic
Political Corruption
See a revealed Mayor in multiple evil visions

Veteran
Finishing the Job
Kill the last evil and end the game

Vigilante
Assassination
Shoot a revealed Mayor survive until the end of the game
Remorseless
Kill multiple innocent townies in a single game

Ambusher
Discount Crusader
Ambush someone visiting a fellow Mafia member

Disguiser
Something's Wrong
Be killed while disguised as a revealed Mayor or as the Veteran that shot you
Just be Yourself
Win a game without disguising once

Godfather
Rigged Election
Be pardoned with the only innocent voters being other Mafia members

Mafioso
Completely Helpless
Have the Godfather send you to your death while voting to attack someone else

Jester
Consolation Prize
Live until the end of a game

Serial Killer
Bloodbath
Kill 3 people in a single night

Medusa
No U
Stone the person who killed you

[cob709]

Medusa
No U
Stone the person who killed you

REVERSE CARD

[Ezradekezra]

Bumping the thread because I thought of some new achievements.

Transporter
Real Estate Agent
Transport the same person 3 nights in a row

Blackmailer
Take it to the Grave
Blackmail someone that died the same night

Framer
He did it, I Swear!
Frame a revealed Mayor

Vampire
Impeachment
Convert a revealed Mayor

[cob709]

Bumping the thread because I thought of some new achievements.

Transporter
Real Estate Agent
Transport the same person 3 nights in a row

Blackmailer
Take it to the Grave
Blackmail someone that died the same night

Framer
He did it, I Swear!
Frame a revealed Mayor

Vampire
Impeachment
Convert a revealed Mayor

omg these 4 are so good

[Brilliand]

Blackmailer
Take it to the Grave
Blackmail someone that died the same night

Framer
He did it, I Swear!
Frame a revealed Mayor

These are kinda gamethrowy. I don't think they would ever actually be beneficial to do.

[Ezradekezra]

I figured that some of these scenarios are supposed to happen accidentally, like if the Mayor gets transported or if the Framer gets witched. Some of the achievements already in the game are kinda throwy like this, too, such as the one for ambushing Pestilence, or the one for dying to a Serial Killer as a Jailor.

[Ezradekezra]

Here's another based on a game I just played. 3 Jesters + Jailor + Pestilence at the end, and it went until N11. We managed to get one of the Jesters lynched, but then the Jailor jailed Pestilence. (after they inno'd the Jester, why?)

Jester
FINALLY!
Get lynched D10 or later

[ABadWord]

I'd like to make a statement on Brilliand's point about gamethrowing achievements.
Achievements like "It's getting hot in here- Ignite yourself", have bee,n around for years by now. They have been sanctioned by the developers and personally I am iffy on if they should be in the game.
However, that is not what this thread is about. This is about forging new achievements to give merit points and encourage play, while being fun tokens of victory or shame. Speaking of that,

M O R E

Bodyguard
-War on The Mob
Kill the last Mafia member or Coven member.
(what is a Coven if not a magical mob?)

Medium
-A Curse Upon You!
Die night one.
-Didn't we Just Talk?
Have the person you seance die.
-This Is Pointless
Seance a Survivor.

Vampire Hunter
-Sorry Boss
Stake a Revealed Mayor.

Blackmailer
-Dirt on Everyone
Blackmail five different people.

Forger
-Will of Few Words
Forge a will with only 10-15 characters in it.
-Ham Sandwich
Forge a will with the only text being "Ham Sandwich"
(Secret Achievement)
-Potty Will
Forge a will with five swears.
(Not slurs, stuff like Flummery and Tarnation)

Framer
-I Didn't Even Do Anything
Frame someone who already appears suspicious, that isn't a Mafia member.

Janitor
-Spa Day
Fail to clean someone that lived through a Mafia attack.
-One Last Job
Clean someone that killed you.

Amnesiac
-Never Even Went to School
Die night 1.

Jester
-SO HAPPY
Be pardoned off the stand.
-The Ultimatum
Be hanged when there are 3 people left alive (yourself included).
-Ending on a Bad Note
Be hanged on the last chance to hang.
(this means that when town has put up and Innoed 2 different people in one day, if you are then hanged you get the 'chievement)
-Not Funny
Die night 1.
(give him defense N1 please!)

General

-Oh I won?
Win alone as a Survivor, Executioner, Jester, or Witch.
-In Love
Win Fifty Lovers games.
-Town of Chance
Win 50 games of All Any.
-Town of Chaos Magic
Win 50 Coven all any games.
-I Vant to Drink Your Bleeh
Win 50 Draculas Palace games.
-Very Important Player
Win 50 VIP games.
-Scummy
Win 50 Town Traitor games.
-Crummy
Win 50 Town Traitor Coven games.
-Think Fast!
Win 50 Rapid games .
('Member Rapid)
-"Creative"
Win 50 Custom games.
-"Magical"
Win 50 Coven Custom games.
-The Colors!
Win 50 Rainbow Mode games.
-Never Forgive
Win 50 Mafia Returns games.

[OreCreeper]

MAYOR
Don't celebrate too early:
- Reveal during a 1v1.

BODYGUARD:
Not going down this time:
- Defend someone from an attack and survive

VIGILANTE:
An unexpected ally:
- Be witched into shooting an evil


JAILOR:
Impeached:
- Execute a Town Traitor mayor after they've revealed.

[dolphina]

I've come up with some ideas (some original, some rebranded achievements conceived here):

Vigilante:

Justice Fails: Have all three of your bullets fail to kill.
Justice Prevails: Have all three of your bullets kill Mafia or Coven members.
Doctor...!: Have all three of your bullets fail to kill due to a Doctor

Doctor:

Attempted Counseling: Heal a Serial Killer who kills you the same night.
Just Slap a Band-Aid on it: Heal someone incinerated by an Arsonist.
Vigilante...!: Heal three people whose cause of death would be from a Vigilante.

Jailor:

Having Fun, Call Again Later: Get roleblocked Night 1.
This is Pointless: Get witched Night 1.
No Fun for Prisoners: Have your jailed target receive an attempted roleblocking.

Lookout:

I Did Not Need to See That: Watch someone get roleblocked.
Occult Doings: Watch someone get witched.
Now That's Just Overkill: Watch someone die in three different ways.

[TheFluffyWaffleV2]

Did somebody say COVEN EXCLUSIVES
(some aren’t, but all roles have atleast 1)

Bodyguard:
-Yes Ma’am
Attack someone on the same night you are controlled.

Doctor:
-Ain’t That Swell
Attempt to heal someone attacked by a fully powered up Juggernaut.

Escort:
-Wear This Bag
Roleblock a gazing Medusa.

Investigator:
-Double Checking
Get different results for the same person in a game.

-You’re Not On The List
Investigate Pestilence.

Jailor:
-You Stink
Jail Pestilence.

Lookout:
-Shy Town
While watching 3 people, go the first 3 nights without seeing anybody.

-We Are Fools
While visiting a gazing Medusa, see 3 other people.

Mayor:
-You’ll Regret That
While revealed, win a Pirate duel.

Medium:
-Doing Great, You?
Speak in dead chat while 5 or more non-Town members are dead, and there are no dead Townies.

-I’m Something Of A Witch Myself
Speak to 4 dead Coven members.

Retributionist:
-You’re The Messiah
Resurrect a Crusader and save someone.

Sheriff:
-Nice Book
Interrogate the holder of the Necronomicon.

Spy:
-Running Around Town
See a total of 7 evils visit.

Transporter:
-Olé!
Make a Juggernaut attack themself.

Vampire Hunter:
-Unholy Savior
Attack a Vampire who gets protected by a Guardian Angel.

Veteran:
-Don’t Backpedal
Alert while being Pirated.

Vigilante:
-Here’s Your Tip
Shoot a Poisoner the night you die from poison.



Blackmailer:
-Would Be A Shame If We...
Hear a Guardian Angel whisper to their target.

Consigliere:
-I Know You!
Investigate a Pirate, then get pirated the next night.

Consort:
-So Big (insert my pfp here)
Role block a Juggernaut.

Disguiser:
-Betrayal
Be killed by a Coven member while disguise as another Coven member.

Forger:
-0/20 Vision
Forge a Psychic.

Framer:
-Learn How To Read
Frame the holder of the Necronomicon.

Godfather:
-Nothing Like That Bodyguard
Be attacked by a Crusader.

Janitor:
-Yarr Dead, Matey
Clean a Pirate.

Mafioso:
-Gang War
Kill 3 members of the Coven.


Amnesiac:
-Bad First Impression
Be poisoned on the night you remember a Coven role.

Survivor:
-Can’t We Talk This Out?
Be alive during a Mafia and Coven 1 v 1.


Executioner:
-Coup De Grâce
Have your target lynched while they are poisoned.

-That’s Too Bad
Have your target lynched while they are the target of a Guardian Angel.

Jester:
-Not Funny, Huh?
Haunt Pestilence.



Arsonist:
-Charlie’s Inferno
Kill a Guardian Angel and their target in a single night.

Serial Killer:
-Don’t Sidestep
Attack a Pirate that roleblocks you.

Werewolf:
-Move, Witch
Kill the Coven Leader indirectly with your rampage.


Vampire:
-Fall from Grace
Convert a Guardian Angel who has turned into a Survivor.

[Ezradekezra]

Here's another I thought of:

Spy
The New PotC Movie Looks Great
See your target die to a Pirate

[Ezradekezra]

Bumping because I thought of M O R E.

Lovers
It's Overrated
Win as a Loverless Evil

Survivor
Stowaway
Win alongside a (living) Pirate

Coven Town Traitor
Recycling
Be on a team with a Necromancer and a Traitor Retributionist

Potion Master
Making Amends
Successfully heal 2 non-Coven members in a game
Staying Hidden
Make it through the first 5 nights without using an attack potion