Kirize wrote:I didnt know you could contradict yourself in one sentencekookeekwisp wrote:Dont single out Arso cause it kills slower!
Kirize12 wrote:But...wouldn't allowing the "Town" disguiser to be revived add even more depth?
They wouldn't be guaranteed to be considered Town. That's the point. The fact that a Disguiser can be revived would mean that the Town would have to be suspicious of anyone who got revived as long as a Disguiser was a possibility.AdamBladeTaylor wrote:Honestly I think it would be far too powerful for the Mafia. They'd get a Mafia member who's now pretty much guaranteed to be considered Town, as well as the voting power that goes with it.
Remember, getting the revive will not be easy for the Mafia. They have to convince the Ret that the dead Disguiser is Town, which requires a convincing will (including the role the Disguiser was copying, which the disguiser doesn't automatically know.) It's not automatic, the way the Retributionist is currently; it requires serious work and effort on the part of the Mafia.Letting the Mafia get the revive would massively shift the balance of power in Mafia's favour. Right now, killing Mafia early is Town's best chance to try and keep some form of control. As the more Mafia members are alive, the less votes Town gets, and the more people to spread confusion.
AdamBladeTaylor wrote:Kirize12 wrote:But...wouldn't allowing the "Town" disguiser to be revived add even more depth?
Honestly I think it would be far too powerful for the Mafia. They'd get a Mafia member who's now pretty much guaranteed to be considered Town, as well as the voting power that goes with it. Not to mention wasting the Ret's ability.
Basically making the Ret's ability fail, would give the Ret itself more depth (cause right now it's a very boring and one note role). They'd have to weigh the decision of revealing to point out the fake role (even if through whispers, giving a BM a chance to find out), compared to staying quiet to keep their role hidden.
Letting the Mafia get the revive would massively shift the balance of power in Mafia's favour. Right now, killing Mafia early is Town's best chance to try and keep some form of control. As the more Mafia members are alive, the less votes Town gets, and the more people to spread confusion.
GameThrowerOfficials wrote:When are you idiots gonna fix the mayor??
Kirize12 wrote:GameThrowerOfficials wrote:When are you idiots gonna fix the mayor??
Maybe a bit more respectful
But I agree that the Mayor needs to be able to be whispered to and healed. Whispered to because taking away core mechanics is terrible for balance and healthy gameplay, as well as making the TS slot more swingy than it possibly could be, and healed because not being able to be protected by a doctor but being bale to be protected by a bodyguard creates a weakness that is essentially based on RNG. We get it, Town is OP, but balance is nerfing where it's needed and buffing where it's needed, not nerfing town and buffing evils to the point where town loses majority Day 2. Balance means equal odds of victory.
Aazoth wrote:Can't log in. anyone know when the servers will be up and running for play again?
Kirize12 wrote:awesome5000 wrote:Kirize12 wrote:GameThrowerOfficials wrote:When are you idiots gonna fix the mayor??
Maybe a bit more respectful
But I agree that the Mayor needs to be able to be whispered to and healed. Whispered to because taking away core mechanics is terrible for balance and healthy gameplay, as well as making the TS slot more swingy than it possibly could be, and healed because not being able to be protected by a doctor but being bale to be protected by a bodyguard creates a weakness that is essentially based on RNG. We get it, Town is OP, but balance is nerfing where it's needed and buffing where it's needed, not nerfing town and buffing evils to the point where town loses majority Day 2. Balance means equal odds of victory.
What the fuck
I'll only support the Doctor healing if Town Power is implemented. Mayor is already powerful without healing and without the whispering.
If Town Power isn't implemented, still do what I say, but make the reveal a night action that can be roleblocked and take away a vote. (or both extra votes - nothing wrong with innocent child)
Aazoth wrote:what are Innocent Child and Citizen? I looked them up but i can't find anything on them anywhere. Am I just looking in the wrong place?
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 31 guests