Town of Salem Game Forums

Jamezbeast wrote:Hold on... I think I've got this...

/vote Jamezbeast

Uh... Wait... Perhaps that wasn't the best move...

TheNightmareFox wrote:

Jamezbeast wrote:

TheNightmareFox wrote:

Exacerbated wrote:Also I don’t think people listed their night result

If your next post doesn’t contain night results you are confirmed scum

This is fucking scummy as fuck
First off not all roles have night results
Second some people have yet to claim so why force them out incase they are important
And three
What about roles that it would be better they didn't say What they are
And what of TK is vigi
They wont have night results

The first line to me seems such a jerk reaction which to me just isn't how a townie would react- especially not somebody who claimed cit.

I would like to hear your thought process, as in a game with citizens we need to try and "confirm" people fairly quickly or we will hand the initiative to scum.

If somebody has night results and withholds them, and then dies the next night, they become useless, and more importantly the initiative has been handed to mafia.

I have been really struggling to get a read on you, and this post for me makes you lean scum.

Mass claiming and confirming with out TP dead is a horrible idea
It's just giving scum a checklist of who to kill
And if you notice
I reacted like that before or similarly before
Yet you didn't scum read that
And yea if they die the next night
But as I just stated
Claiming roles is just making a checklist for mafia to mow us down

non271103 wrote:I am Lookout, now, does that help you find scum?

non271103 wrote:

MafiaMenace wrote:Don't vote me, I claim Survivor.

ALWAYS LYNCH SURV CLAIMS
I am the mayor!

non271103 wrote:

cupcakeaj2 wrote:I can easily confirm myself.

All I need is someone who wants to go out and claim that they aren't Cit

Founded Consig

gabby100 wrote:

Exacerbated wrote:By the end of today everyone posts full reads, I’m working on them right now

only 5 people well 6 but thats blue havent posted their reads yet

non
you but thats coming soon so
koishi
claudia
and cupcake

Exacerbated wrote:I think I'll have to resume my Jamezbeast analysis when this non/cupcake situation resolves.

However, I think Claudia is Town.

I took a look at 14C, an early game post where she was Mafia, which I believe encapsulates a very wolfy mindset.

ClaudiaM25, 14C, Mafia wrote:

LOLingHyena wrote:

ClaudiaM25 wrote:

LOLingHyena wrote:In that case, welcome! Be sure to ask any questions if you're confused about anything that's happening or how things work.

Thanks!

I am catching up with the reading and trying to figure out who is good and who is bad here I wouldn't want to random vote for lynching someone though...

After you've caught up and read the thread, can you post the three biggest things or events that stood out to you? They can be suspicious things, things that you think might be tell that someone (or someone(s)) is town, or whatever. Just wanna get an idea about what you're thinking about while you're reading the thread.

Sure do!

First thing that struck me was that people started voting from the very first begining it was like random lynch, which on long term i don't think will take us far (risk lynchin' good fellows), even thought the reasonings were based on the attitude they had on former games/events. Ok, they had some strategies they used before, the chances to do the same are quite high, but still...what are the proofs? I know I wouldn't like to be judged like that...

I actually find it suspicious (in game) when someone accuses another one without any proofs in the actual context or he/she is very quiet(but that's a double-edged sword - they can either be mafia or an important townie that doesn't want to stand up) but this is not the case here all of you are very talkative ... But still, you guys know each other better than me, i just landed here, let me get accustomed to you and will be back with some more insights :p

I got a bit lost between the non-game related posts but it was a fun but also a bit tiring loosing

I embrace non's feelings since we are newbies and I will let myself driven by gut (let's call it female intuition) when i say that i have a feeling of peacefull townies coming from you and TeamMystic at least (arguments: the interest coming from u to see how i think and the fact that you guys try to read everyone and interpret their behaviours demo that u are one of the good ones and try to guard the group interest)

But as I said above, i need more time to know you guys for a better "judgement"...

Note the extremely low ( content / post length ) ratio. It's a giant wall with a lot of words, but almost completely devoid of content.

Also note the wishy-washy tone. She makes a few fence-sitting hedges like "actually find it suspicious (in game) when someone accuses another one without any proofs in the actual context or he/she is very quiet(but that's a double-edged sword - they can either be mafia or an important townie that doesn't want to stand up" that allows her to keep her options open for mislynches later in the game.

Also note her absolute fear of pointing fingers. She doesn't mention anything specific, she just implies something about a vague group of "random lynchers" are up to something sinister, which is actually very convenient for mafia: create a bigger suspect pool so that other townies might pick up on it and then turns around and accuses those townies who fell into her trap later in the game of being Mafia for pushing mislynches. All the while her hands stay perfectly clean!

However, this game she's different. She shows some uncertainty here and there, but I don't see her pushing an agenda quite like the post I showed you guys above.

Her reads day 2 are a lot more matter-of-factly expressed, and her posts actually have content in them.

MafiaMenace wrote:

Exacerbated wrote:dear god

7c flashbacks

non may be ti.
But he took 3 fucking years to claim.
And all around acts scummy and hist posts are the same as your Claudia's scum meta analysis.
Usually non is way better.

UnnoticedKoishi wrote:

ClaudiaM25 wrote:

UnnoticedKoishi wrote:

ClaudiaM25 wrote:Uhm..yes?

Unless we have a counterclaim sometime today, cake should not be lynched.
I am aware about my contradiction, but I have (attempted to) explain myself in that post

Noted that, I just stated that I am sticking to my vote against Foxie since from the begining i had a hunch on him

Ohhhhhhhh
I thought you voted cake, for some reason
Ignore me Kill me, that was embarrassing

ClaudiaM25 wrote:@BasedBlue - anything from you to convince me you're not mafia? Why wouldn't we vote you up today?
Cupcake claimed invest and asked several times for a claim from Jolt...

cupcakeaj2 wrote:Joltik=Cit or Gf.
That was why I wanted his role.
-_-
Now can you all stop voting me already?

I townread Jolt/Koishi though... What did you find not-townish in Jolt/Koishi's topics that you insisted so much on them?

UnnoticedKoishi wrote:

ClaudiaM25 wrote:Uhm..yes?

Unless we have a counterclaim sometime today, cake should not be lynched.
I am aware about my contradiction, but I have (attempted to) explain myself in that post

UnnoticedKoishi wrote:As it has been proven in previous games, a hard-claim this early does not mean that someone is confirmed to be that role
Yes, cake has claimed invest and yes, she claims to have investigated me, but that hardly believable when you look as her ISO and see what she has said
It isn't exactly convincing

TheNightmareFox wrote:

gabby100 wrote:

TheNightmareFox wrote:

khakha1036 wrote:Say something Im panic

Hi panic I'm Nathan

yeah.. No
/vote TNF

Your voting me for doing a bad joke
-_-
/vote gabby

TheNightmareFox wrote:The "trying to hard" townie
*shrug*
I might be trying to hard
But I'm usually A PL in the TG Episodes
So I'm used to having to try very hard to be townie as otherwise I get PLd

cupcakeaj2 wrote:Joltik=Cit or Gf.
That was why I wanted his role.
-_-
Now can you all stop voting me already?

non271103 wrote:Welp, I don't think there's much I can read on since I am not fimiliar with any of you and I'm bad at D1 reads but Ill see what I can do later.

MafiaMenace wrote:

non271103 wrote:

MafiaMenace wrote:I feel cupcake is our best bet for a lynch today.
Second by Syanna and TNF.

Who's Syanna?

basedblue.

MafiaMenace wrote:

gabby100 wrote:hey james what do you think of the game so far? you having fun?

Gabby unnecessary talk like that will get you hanged, and if you say there isn't a problem with it, in TFM 62 Evan asked you an off-topic question and you told him to stay on task. :/
Not really AI but still I don't like how much effort you are putting in.

Blackwolfe99 wrote:/unvote
Just waiting until I can get a good read in.