Town of Salem Game Forums

chitownmvp01 wrote:Thanks for hosting, mel!

Seconded.

chitownmvp01 wrote:

LOLingHyena wrote:Yeah, I deserved getting lynch D2. I don't think I was doing a really good job communicating what I was trying to say. Not to mention, I was getting flustered each time people didn't react to me in the way I thought they would to my reads and thoughts. I didn't understand what was going on and why things were happening.

With that said, I don't regret making the last minute push on Gent, even if the push itself was really bad. I genuinely thought he was scum.

Anyway, apologies for sucking this game!

Yeah I agree with the assessment of yourself, but I thought you were town after your Gent push because if you're scum trying to get suspicion onto someone else and off of you, the chance of success of getting Gent lynched is pretty low. You also didn't do much to bus milte, which is what scum should definitely do in that situation (Gent did it).

Anyways, GG! 2-0 since ending my VFM curse, hopefully I will keep up the win streak.

Yeah, GG! Good to see you continuing your VFM win streak! It's a shame we didn't really get a chance to play together longer after you replaced in.

heytheregirl17 wrote:wait is it over?

It seems to be? I'm sorry that I didn't defend you sooner. I thought I'd be able to clear you if I was able to just talk with you more, but I hadn't even realized you were hammered by the time I actually got a chance to talk to you.

Yeah, I deserved getting lynch D2. I don't think I was doing a really good job communicating what I was trying to say. Not to mention, I was getting flustered each time people didn't react to me in the way I thought they would to my reads and thoughts. I didn't understand what was going on and why things were happening.

With that said, I don't regret making the last minute push on Gent, even if the push itself was really bad. I genuinely thought he was scum.

Anyway, apologies for sucking this game!

For those of you who are having trouble keeping up with the game, I encourage you to vote for Gent. Even if he ends up being town, I promise you that you'll have an easier time solving the game after he is dead (especially those of you who don't know how to read him or are reading him null). There's a huge difference between having a good time with friends and being disruptive to the point where others aren't wanting to read the thread. That and this general attitude of people being shitters don't promote cooperation between town. It's not only anti-town, it's also toxic to the game.

As for reasons why I'm scumreading Gent in particular, I feel like I'm talking to a brick wall whenever I'm arguing with him. He can't be this fucking stupid. Even if I wasn't clear about what I meant whenever he responded to me with a "wut", he could have been more clear about what parts of what I said didn't make sense to him. Not to mention, it feels like he's just being intentionally dense in general. Until I get a detailed explanation for why he's scumreading me and until he tells me which parts of anything I've said don't make sense to him, I'm not taking my vote off of him. If he gets lynched and flips town, so be it. In my eyes, Gent is not town.

chitownmvp01 wrote:TPA accused milte before milte accused TPA?

I also don't remember the last time milte had at least 83 posts in a game, lol.

Yes, TPA came out with a red check on Milte before Milte CC'd with a red check on TPA.

ryanyb wrote:

LOLingHyena wrote:[*] As Ryan, there's been a lot of memeing, even into D2 it seems, and a lot of caps. From a purely subjective point of view, some of it has been disruptive, which is just one of many reasons I'm scum reading certain folks, but I might be the only player who thinks that. [/list]

Lots of us have quite a bit of report with each other, and we're kinda letting that all come out in the form of memes since it's been a while since we all played together.

Ah, okay. I didn't know. I wish you guys would've explained this to me earlier when I asked about it.

LOLingHyena wrote:

chitownmvp01 wrote:Hi. I haven't read. A quick summary would be appreciated. I'm also in college now, so I don't have as much time to play, but I still wanted to play.

I'm so happy to see you.

Here's a summary from my point of view:

• Near the beginning of D2, both TPA and Milte claimed cop with red checks on each other. Most of us believe TPA is the real cop because Milte didn't act too towny D1. Plus, it seemed like Milte claimed cop in reaction to TPA claiming cop.
• HTG was lynched D1. Both she and TPA were both acting different than they normally do, and because HTG seemed to be sheeping Cow's reads rather than coming up with her own.
• We've decided to lynch outside of the cop claims because it narrows down PoE. One of TPA/Milte is confirmed scum/town (Milte is scum), so we thought lynching an unknown (and checking an unknown, too) would help confirm people as town or scum faster.
• Right now, it seems like I'm the potential lynch today. It also looks like Mdb is being considered as an option.
• As Ryan, there's been a lot of memeing, even into D2 it seems, and a lot of caps. From a purely subjective point of view, some of it has been disruptive, which is just one of many reasons I'm scum reading certain folks, but I might be the only player who thinks that.

As Ryan said** rather

chitownmvp01 wrote:Hi. I haven't read. A quick summary would be appreciated. I'm also in college now, so I don't have as much time to play, but I still wanted to play.

I'm so happy to see you.

Here's a summary from my point of view:

• Near the beginning of D2, both TPA and Milte claimed cop with red checks on each other. Most of us believe TPA is the real cop because Milte didn't act too towny D1. Plus, it seemed like Milte claimed cop in reaction to TPA claiming cop.
• HTG was lynched D1. Both she and TPA were both acting different than they normally do, and because HTG seemed to be sheeping Cow's reads rather than coming up with her own.
• We've decided to lynch outside of the cop claims because it narrows down PoE. One of TPA/Milte is confirmed scum/town (Milte is scum), so we thought lynching an unknown (and checking an unknown, too) would help confirm people as town or scum faster.
• Right now, it seems like I'm the potential lynch today. It also looks like Mdb is being considered as an option.
• As Ryan, there's been a lot of memeing, even into D2 it seems, and a lot of caps. From a purely subjective point of view, some of it has been disruptive, which is just one of many reasons I'm scum reading certain folks, but I might be the only player who thinks that.

TheParanoidAndroid wrote:

LOLingHyena wrote:

TheParanoidAndroid wrote:Cykas either LOL or milte

What does Cykas mean?

Not nice russkan

Ah, okay.

@Mdb, can you post some general thoughts and reads on the game? I don't have much of a sense about where you are right now. At the very least, what are your thoughts on Macca, Gent, Moon, Cow, Ryan, and me? Some brief explanation for each would be helpful, too.

TheParanoidAndroid wrote:Cykas either LOL or milte

What does Cykas mean?

MaccaMania wrote:/vote HTG

HTG/MDB ftw. MDB's "it is heytheregirl though" was wolfy, especially after it was said by someone else. MDB might have thought that bc someone else said it he could use it as a way to defend htg or smth.

I could see Cow being scum with HTG, although I'm not confident with it. The early interaction they had was really weird, and it felt like Cow was going soft on HTG rather then calling her out on it

I stopped reading after the thread got clogged up with waifu shit, so I'm a little bit behind.

Macca, when you get a chance to, can you explain why you waited until you placed your vote for HTG to express concern about the interaction you mentioned?

First question: Gent and Cow, why did you guys clog up the thread near the end of D1? What was the point of that whole interaction? It was really disruptive to the game (see Macca and Mdb for evidence).

All I ask is that you guys don't quicklynch me because I still have a bunch of questions that I want to ask people (as well as a bunch of unanswered questions from D1). I am town, and I'm not just going to roll over for you guys.

TrueGent wrote:if we are lynching outside the cops I'd lynch hyena, who tpa has already said they arent checking

I'm tempted to actually say this is probably the best play, but I still want to scum hunt more today and have a chance to prove that I'm town.

Also, I don't think BD outs right now unless they're about to get lynched.

No, in this case, I think I agree with Cow. I do think we lynch outside of the cop claims today even though Milte is confirmed scum. It saves us time having to figure out someone else's alignment. And, of course, the BD just protects TPA tonight, and we have another cop check tomorrow.

CatgirlMaple wrote:

TheParanoidAndroid wrote:Like I'd just say "lol bye milte" and start killing both PRs if I was in that situation

If we lynch inside the cops today, we are not lynching inside the POE, and are therefore not getting closer to PoE via cop. If we lynch outside the cops, it forces the cops to say "lol bye milte" and shoot at the cop, which brings us even closer to PoE via cop

not lynching inside the cops is just mathematically superior here

I think I see what he's saying here. Basically, we know the Milte is scum. There are still a lot of unknowns though. We can get rid of the some of the unknowns by lynching them, hence lynching someone outside the cop claims.

ryanyb wrote:

LOLingHyena wrote:

TheParanoidAndroid wrote:Prolly won't peek hyena he might just need to be lynched

I think macca/mdb/wabbit

I'm okay with this. On that note, I wouldn't reveal who you're checking out load because mafia might kill whoever you say you're going to check.

I mean
or they can try to kill the cop.

Yes, that, too. I'm dumb.

TrueGent wrote:

LOLingHyena wrote:The fact that Gent is attacking from this HTG angle rather than from the angle that I was actively defending Milte makes me question my scumread on Gent now.

what

It doesn't make sense to me why you (or anyone else) as scum would use this HTG stuff, which doesn't make any sense to me, as evidence that I'm scum instead of using the fact that I defended Milte, who most of us agree is scum now, for illogical reasons.

The fact that Gent is attacking from this HTG angle rather than from the angle that I was actively defending Milte makes me question my scumread on Gent now.

TrueGent wrote:"yeah I didnt care if htg was lynched lmao"
^what you just said

Okay, I don't know if I'm explaining myself in a way that makes sense or if this is a case where I'm not understanding what you're saying. Yes, I do care that we're down one town, but there was no way for me to know for sure whether HTG was town or not. That's why I tried asking them questions instead of defending them from you guys. How does this imply that I don't want to take responsibility for HTG's lynch?

TrueGent wrote:

LOLingHyena wrote:

TrueGent wrote:It shows they dont want to be held responsible for HTGs lynch, which is objectively wolfy

How does it show that I don't want to be held responsible for HTG's lynch?

How does it show that you want htg lynched

It doesn't show that I want HTG lynched. It doesn't show that I don't want HTG lynched that day either. Like my earlier big post D1, that post was me stating where my head was at in that moment. I'm not arguing that I wasn't being indecisive about HTG and TPA, because yes, I wasn't sure which, if either, I wanted to lynch at that point. I felt like I still needed to ask more questions before I'd be able to come to a conclusion, which is why I was trying to ask questions, why I was asking for a vote count, and why I didn't want to end the day yet. I don't know where my vote would've landed in the end. I didn't expect the day to end so soon after I was told that you guys didn't want to end the day yet.

With that said, at the time of my last post D1, based on the last set of interactions I had with TPA, I probably would have ended up voting for HTG. I just didn't realize that the day had already ended. However, as far as being held responsibile for HTG's lynch, I could care less if you guys hold me responsible for it or not. I'm not upset that HTG flipped town.