Okay so, may be ruining the point of some pushes or something here, maybe not, idk I'm new and confused.
Why would lynching watchme here be any sort of good? TBH I thought it was a push by Arc to put pressure on chubby and it seems to have at least gotten responses (which is why I waited this long to ask about it, in case it was for that reason).
-If watchme is vig, lynching them now would cost town a PR, which would be dumb unless watchme is real dumb with his shots (which, I mean, I still think kmen was a bad move considering the possibility of a bluff and the fact saber flipped mafia).
-If watchme isn't vig, then lynching them now would probably be good, but there's still another mafia member, so it's not like there's an extra kill during the night (unless I'm missing something?) additionally, if he's the vengeful, we actually lose someone else, iirc?
-If watchme is vig and we don't lynch, then we will lose 1 to mafia kill, 1 to vig kill (assumedly), so at least one town member. If they crosskill, then while we don't have as much info, that's /still/ less townspeople dead at the end of the day. While we don't necessarily gain more information, I don't think it's a bad thing to keep more people alive (but again, may be wrong, I'm new and don't know how things always play out).
I thought arc was town but I just don't see how pushing watchme was at all helpful to us unless it was to generate pressure on someone else.
I'd appreciate if chubby, fen, and arc could share their thoughts on my thot process