Town of Salem Game Forums

Phone0Ix wrote:

Whirlwindwarrior wrote:

ChamAlien wrote:

watchme1 wrote:Slightly scummy reads - Ph0ne - acting rather quiet, not inputting too much into discussiong but enough to stay on the side of unnoticed which gives me similar vibes to 18B and vfm51 when he was scummy.
- Seth - some of the things he says is just plain scummy but people have said that is what he does so I'm turning a blind eye to it for now.

Everyone else is either a null read or a slight town read. (aside from ym earlier post on dota being most townie and whirl being scummy)

This guy only read Www, phone and Seth as scum. Www and Seth are pr and dead. He never mentioned phone after this post.
S/S?

Not really. I don't think watchme calls out a buddy for lurking like that.

Who says I am lurking? Once I read I remember I posted at least once everytime. Just not rlly much online and I dont post much

watchme1 wrote:

Whirlwindwarrior wrote:

watchme1 wrote:

Whirlwindwarrior wrote:I'm the cop. Watchme is mafia.

/vote watchme1

Hi cop, I'm doctor and healed you last night. I wouldn't even have thought you'd be cop since you were my scum read.

Reason I didn't heal dota last night was cause I dont think mafia would want to take out a confirmed cit and rather hunt prs.

I don't believe it.

I didn't believe you were cop until you claimed it since I scum read you. So I thought there would be no way you'd be cop and I believe I was the only one who scum read you during day 1.

I'm going to sleep right now (currently 10:44pm), tomorrow I'll do an iso on albanix and qva and see if I can make anything out of it

Whirlwindwarrior wrote:

watchme1 wrote:

Whirlwindwarrior wrote:I'm the cop. Watchme is mafia.

/vote watchme1

Hi cop, I'm doctor and healed you last night. I wouldn't even have thought you'd be cop since you were my scum read.

Reason I didn't heal dota last night was cause I dont think mafia would want to take out a confirmed cit and rather hunt prs.

I don't believe it.

watchme1 wrote:

Whirlwindwarrior wrote:I'm the cop. Watchme is mafia.

/vote watchme1

Hi cop, I'm doctor and healed you last night. I wouldn't even have thought you'd be cop since you were my scum read.

Reason I didn't heal dota last night was cause I dont think mafia would want to take out a confirmed cit and rather hunt prs.

ChamAlien wrote:

watchme1 wrote:Slightly scummy reads - Ph0ne - acting rather quiet, not inputting too much into discussiong but enough to stay on the side of unnoticed which gives me similar vibes to 18B and vfm51 when he was scummy.
- Seth - some of the things he says is just plain scummy but people have said that is what he does so I'm turning a blind eye to it for now.

Everyone else is either a null read or a slight town read. (aside from ym earlier post on dota being most townie and whirl being scummy)

This guy only read Www, phone and Seth as scum. Www and Seth are pr and dead. He never mentioned phone after this post.
S/S?

ChamAlien wrote:Why did you check watchme?

AlbanixAnubibus wrote:I mean, we should wait to see if the Doctor claims they healed you.

MrChuckleteeth wrote:I mean I’m still here I’m just waiting for Seth to be hammered.

AlbanixAnubibus wrote:Are people OK with pushing Seth to L-1?
Because no discussion is actually going on right now.

MrChuckleteeth wrote:

Whirlwindwarrior wrote:

MrChuckleteeth wrote:

Whirlwindwarrior wrote:I think Seth’s post about not caring about getting lynched was too casual for his usual town play style. However, the last game I played Phone was Citizen and did the same thing, so I’m wary of locking him as scum for it.

Your logic is faulty because Phone and Seth are two completely different players and you are using one player's meta to read another player's meta.

Phone doing that does not mean that Seth would also do that, and regardless of whether Seth does it or not, it has 0 correlation to Phone doing it.

Stop trying to fencesit.

I’m aware of that. I’m holding off my vote because it’s close to majority, but this kind of play is solidly within Seth’s scum meta (AtE and claiming early).

Glad you clarified.

I will retract my comment about fencesitting, but don't think you're off the hook.

MrChuckleteeth wrote:

Whirlwindwarrior wrote:I think Seth’s post about not caring about getting lynched was too casual for his usual town play style. However, the last game I played Phone was Citizen and did the same thing, so I’m wary of locking him as scum for it.

Your logic is faulty because Phone and Seth are two completely different players and you are using one player's meta to read another player's meta.

Phone doing that does not mean that Seth would also do that, and regardless of whether Seth does it or not, it has 0 correlation to Phone doing it.

Stop trying to fencesit.

noveiia wrote:I don’t want a mislynch as I don’t believe any of the other wagons are scum so for now I’m going to leave my vote on, what’s in my opinion, the most likely to be scum.
/vote SethTheKing

Qvapil wrote:About watchme, they have a small iso but they didn't joke around much early game, they actively participated in our discussion about night plans, and they gave some detailed scumreads. I think this is fairly townie. In vfm51 they were hedgy with their reads and avoided the thread more.

Qvapil wrote:

Whirlwindwarrior wrote:

noveiia wrote:All for lynching Seth before the fifth page say “Aye”. (It’s a joke before anyone comes at me).

Also I don’t like this post, it seems too worried about getting scumread. Could be from prior experience, but I still want to keep an eye on it.

I find it weird that whirl made this post on noveiia but instead of pushing her for this, decided to focus on the fact that she made a mistake later. I'm not sure what to make of this though.

ChamAlien wrote:

Whirlwindwarrior wrote:

Phone0Ix wrote:

Whirlwindwarrior wrote:

noveiia wrote:

dota2reporter wrote:oh btw noveiia sorry for mislynching you in nfm65 xD

This is my third game. In the past two games I was town and I was lynched twice as town. Apparently I’m very scummy.

This is also a lie. They were Sheriff in 18B and weren’t lynched.

/vote noveiia

And you can die for this

/vote WhirlwindWarrior

It might be just me but this post feels oppurtinistic if that is the rigjt word (I believe that is what it means)

It’s not opportunistic, they lied about their meta. I think that’s a scum-motivated move that could be used to defend themselves if they receive pressure.

Are you the person in the signup's playerlist?

Phone0Ix wrote:

Whirlwindwarrior wrote:

Phone0Ix wrote:

Whirlwindwarrior wrote:

noveiia wrote:

dota2reporter wrote:oh btw noveiia sorry for mislynching you in nfm65 xD

This is my third game. In the past two games I was town and I was lynched twice as town. Apparently I’m very scummy.

This is also a lie. They were Sheriff in 18B and weren’t lynched.

/vote noveiia

And you can die for this

/vote WhirlwindWarrior

It might be just me but this post feels oppurtinistic if that is the rigjt word (I believe that is what it means)

It’s not opportunistic, they lied about their meta. I think that’s a scum-motivated move that could be used to defend themselves if they receive pressure.

I see now why you think it is scummy, but in my opinion it is NAI. Noveiia is a fairly new player and I think it is more likely to come from a townie that made a honest mistake (becuse scum is more likely to watch words, especially for a newer player)

Phone0Ix wrote:

Whirlwindwarrior wrote:

noveiia wrote:

dota2reporter wrote:oh btw noveiia sorry for mislynching you in nfm65 xD

This is my third game. In the past two games I was town and I was lynched twice as town. Apparently I’m very scummy.

This is also a lie. They were Sheriff in 18B and weren’t lynched.

/vote noveiia

And you can die for this

/vote WhirlwindWarrior

It might be just me but this post feels oppurtinistic if that is the rigjt word (I believe that is what it means)

noveiia wrote:

dota2reporter wrote:oh btw noveiia sorry for mislynching you in nfm65 xD

This is my third game. In the past two games I was town and I was lynched twice as town. Apparently I’m very scummy.