Town of Salem Game Forums

SirCakez wrote:I forgot to write my review, so I'll write one up now!

Scum just got really screwed, both by bad luck and bad plays. They had a really good role set-up, with two NKs, Janitor and Agent, but Agent was useless as the Agent did not tap the Mayor until it was too late and Janitor was useless due to the massclaim day 2. And of course Schultz and Dean both got screwed by gambits/Spy, although Evil's weak play did not help him. Town did not play particularly well, they just lol-won off of the Mayor massclaim and scum misfortune. Though they did not play badly like so many other towns either which is commendable! Particularly I thought ICE, ultiix, glhf3 and TPA (unfortunately not town lol!) had good games. And it seems like most people had fun, so that's a win in my book.

Nopingout wrote:Carried yey

mdb1023 wrote:

OctoOoze wrote:my reads were fire
jk thx for hosting cakez! i had fun getting carried

Same, tho, which is why i probably won't join another game like this again. I honestly don't blame the mafia for giving up in the end.

mdb1023 wrote:I don't think I'll play a game like this again since I really didn't care for the whisper game.

ElusiveBelle wrote:I thought Stalker could change their targets though, what happened to that?

xUltiix wrote:Playing mayor was really fun

glhf3 wrote:

BS4125 wrote:Mayor + Whispers + Non-scummy Town + Logic + Playing the game = Town win

I'd like to think I'd played well as acting Town, couldn't really do anything against a Mayor saying I'm scummy plus either defend against no information.
Funny thing is, I clicked on the thread one day thinking this is going good for me, then the first message I say is "We are lynching BS today" - game shattered

I couldn't read you so you were my d2 invest. check.

BS4125 wrote:Mayor + Whispers + Non-scummy Town + Logic + Playing the game = Town win

I'd like to think I'd played well as acting Town, couldn't really do anything against a Mayor saying I'm scummy plus either defend against no information.
Funny thing is, I clicked on the thread one day thinking this is going good for me, then the first message I say is "We are lynching BS today" - game shattered

TheParanoidAndroid wrote:

ElusiveBelle wrote:TPA's gambit was so obvious though and I even called it as such.
How people ended up believing it astounds me.

The fact it was right though is amusing however but the fact it was bought like hot cakes, just jeez.

Lolno

I knew some of our less bright players would scream Exe so I bashed in the “claim = no more push” and actively pushed for a nightkill if he didn’t claim to avoid that. Shame I literally got fucked by the ridiculous odds of me actually calling out the arso day 1 lmao

ICECLIMBERS wrote:

ICECLIMBERS wrote:And if the spy is actually an agent they'd probably have the mayor tapped so we could hypothetically do a whisper test with a tap target and that target whispering to anybody else.

I don't know how we would do this without outing the spy claim though.

RHawkeye wrote:How far are we from hammer?

RHawkeye wrote:Is hereisme just going to prodge again

xUltiix wrote:Evil is the lynch today
Dont hammer until ice has put down his thoughts
Hammer away when that happens

ICECLIMBERS wrote:I'm probably going to lay out my thoughts tomorrow.