Town of Salem Game Forums

ChubbyMooshroom9 wrote:I hardcarried

This is the second time I wasn't actually on your scum team and ended up being a traitor of sorts to hard carry your team.
You're welcome Chubbs

lucky333123 wrote:If I was a mole it would sadly be very obvious xD

If I was still alive, I would have pushed for an Ici lynch. Why the heck did you guys not push for an Ici lynch....Ici was so obvious.

Rip, I really thought you were a mole. I thought it was genius mafia play to fake a modifier and get two townies lynched potentially more with how you were playing with it.
Oh well, wasn't that good at reading others here apparently just reading the numbers working with that.

I didn't get to partake in day 1, but seems like a good time.

I had fun though since subbing in, definitely some luck involved though but worked out in the end.
Also a win with Jacko, now that doesn't happen every day

I was a legitimate town at first thank you, technically I did want to win with town and I was on to you AtE. I knew the double DGs was sketch and that one was scum, after lucky's death though I flipped sides and harnessed myself to Ici. I was trying to keep track of numbers, which is why I focused on the set up so much, to know when the tides would officially turn with my turn.

I wasn't officially against town until the day after Lucky died and made it official taking the lynch.

Also I was right about the DGs, one being town and the other mafia, it's funny they ended up using the same things the first two nights

Quite a few things had to line up just right to have things go the way they did so that is interesting at least.

Not gunna lie, I was surprised I managed to swing the lynch my way.
That was why I changed my claim to cop, I wouldn't get lynched as death proof.

Icibalus wrote:Elusive if we nightkilled you you'd end up on our team anyway.

True, but I wouldn't have survived the lynch after that.
I soaked up two lynches for you guys

Apparently my deathproof claim saved my ass though in mafia chat. Allowed me to pull the gambit I did since it kept mafia from attacking me.

I liked that the only scum town managed to kill was me, and that was because I took the sword for Ici.

Leyva killed themselves pretty much and Chubby was shot by a neutral.

Hooray

In all reality though, the only reason I jumped ship to the moles was because Lucky died. I was actually pretty sure they were a mole and that town could win pretty easily, so when they flipped town I just kinda figured town was fucked and had no idea on whom the actual moles were. So I just wagoned myself to Ici and pushed to get lynched to swing the numbers.

With that said, since I replaced in, I would have chosen Beloved Princess for the role.

No win for me? Q.Q
I hard carried for them too

We just need Jacko on our side and we can end this. A town killing themselves to take out a mafia member isn't that good for them anyways and changes nothing. We just vote ED instead. 4 would be majority, which we would have, ED dies as well and still game over.

So has anyone figured out my actual role yet? I've been trying to play the line here until I was sure one side could take it and then just kinda went for it.

Icibalus wrote:

Bottlenose wrote:the neutrals will die if they side with you and you will throw thr game if you kill them.

How, exactly, will they, if the town dosen't have majority.

In fact, since you still seem to be unclaimed and are thus more dangerous.

/Vote Bottlenose

/Vote Bottle

I'll just sheep this, have Jacko and Jammy vote this as well then the last mafia can hammer it and game is done. If Jammy and Jacko want to win we can end this now

The fact bottle is trying to dissuade conversation so much is certainly interesting as well....

I'm thinking it is kingmaker actually, it is what makes the most sense. Question is if it is Jammy or Jacko, or even someone else entirely....

I doubt both neutrals have NE wincons. Two NEs with 4 mafia would be a bit of unbalance as well. I think at least one of them is NB instead which is why it hasn't ended. They're essentially the swing vote.

Bottlenose wrote:if ultii is mafia then the game will end and that's it, i wouldn't really worry about his flip that much

i would deal with ate/dragon only if the game doesn't end after lynching ici and elusive

Funny how that would be game over by then wouldn't it? Interesting.

There has to be 4 mafia, that much is a given. Just for balance sake...
If there was a false flip, then both Ici and I cant be mafia and the other is hiding somehow or somewhere... unless my numbers are wrong... but it makes the most sense?
If there wasn't a false flip, and Jacko and Jammy are in fact neutral then that should be gg if they vote ED with the remaining mafia. We'll have to see on that since I am not mafia 100% that should be majority in that case.

I need to think about this more, all I know is I am not part of the 4 mafia that started the game nor do I know who the mafia actually is. I just know me and what has been revealed

15v3v2 Sounds even worse though, especially if the 3 was only because of one of the 15 had a chance to be the 4th.... I think that would be too swingy.... so there has to be 4 mafia at least to start with. I doubt there also only being one neutral so I would believe both Jammy and Jacko. Only one would be 15v4v1 which is even worse with only one KpN.... hmmm... there is too much wonky with this.... and right now the only thing that makes sense might be AtE and Dragon.... or some other pairing that is playing hard ball.

So far 9 town are dead, 1 is known in ED. Totaling 10
2 mafia are dead and unknown how many are left. Assuming 2. Makes 4
So that makes 14 accounted for.
3 neutral claims bumping up to 17. Which leaves three town slots left.

Hmmm, this role list confuses me.... the game couldn't have started with only three mafia, there is no way that would be balanced. But 5 people are fighting for the last 4 town spots among themselves since they don't believe Ici.

Bottle, AtE, ED, Dragon, and Mdb.

14v4v2? That doesn't sound very balanced... but if it is the case then Ici is not mafia and the other two are among those not voting yet. Was I right about Dragon? And potentially AtE?

I'm curious, Jammy and Jacko. If you are both neutral with Survivor wincons, which I kind of doubt, but NE wincon works too, but vote ED. If there is two mafia left they can quick hammer when they want. If not town will know what they are dealing with left, maybe. Who really knows but I'm curious

/Vote EvilD

This is assuming the neutrals are telling the truth and mafia have two members. Then town shouldn't have the numbers to lynch anyways.

mdb1023 wrote:so what you're saying is that I'm mafia? Go look at the day 1 lynch and then tell me that again.

You're not the only one pushing it if I am not mistaken, seemed like most of the town is. Really there should be one mafia blending in and the other blending in with the neutrals at this rate.

Although Bottle trying to strong arm my lynch is cute. Would mafia benefit from a neutral lynch? I think it depends on how many their are. Pushing for another no lynch would grant them another kill for free... hmmm~ interesting