Town of Salem Game Forums

NoodleLick wrote:Gent was too obvious of a target, you should've been on someone else

The most obvious target is usually the one that someone will protect or watch.

I came back after a few hours to see a salt fest.

NoodleLick wrote:
xUltiix wrote:
NoodleLick wrote:
xUltiix wrote:
NoodleLick wrote:
xUltiix wrote:
NoodleLick wrote:
xUltiix wrote:
NoodleLick wrote:
xUltiix wrote:@Noodle

Where is the loss in your FM record
Because this game definitely existed and you lost by going for TrueGent night 1, and acting scummy.
BG death could have been prevented.

I have no idea what you're talking about idiot

Then that is 2 things you are bad at: memory and FM.

You're just as stupid as STAA -_-

NoodleLick wrote:I have no idea what you're talking about idiot

You are the one being salty and insulting people.

I only call you an idiot if you're being one.

Guess who lost the game for their faction?

Our consig, now stop being an idiot

...
How did your consig lose you the game?

Because I didn't, it was bad luck I ran into the BG. Also, lucky sent the consig into the vet.

NOW SHUT UP YOU IDIOT

I sent the consig to someone who didn't really speak and I suspected of being a PR (and you didn't have any opinion/didn't post about a differing opinion), but obviously I didn't know what PR they were. I honestly thought that either Olly or ladd were going to be vet...more likely it being ladd. Thus Micheal, really good job! You played well in my opinion!

HalkInHunt wrote:
lucky333123 wrote:
HalkInHunt wrote:
lucky333123 wrote:
HalkInHunt wrote:
/kill Halk

Sorry Halk. I really wanted to kill you the whole entire game xD

Lol
This is funny
Should've killed me N1 man

Haha, I was thinking about it, but I was thinking you may have just been citizen.

I am more townie as PR than as citizen because i care more about the game

I actually couldn't tell the difference. Were you a PR in the other game I played with you?

Have we played other games?

Yep. I think you replaced into a game I was in.

HalkInHunt wrote:
lucky333123 wrote:
HalkInHunt wrote:
/kill Halk

Sorry Halk. I really wanted to kill you the whole entire game xD

Lol
This is funny
Should've killed me N1 man

Haha, I was thinking about it, but I was thinking you may have just been citizen.

I am more townie as PR than as citizen because i care more about the game

I actually couldn't tell the difference. Were you a PR in the other game I played with you?

Varanus wrote:By not attacking the FMMod N1 every game

Yep a very good plan

HalkInHunt wrote:
/kill Halk

Sorry Halk. I really wanted to kill you the whole entire game xD

Lol
This is funny
Should've killed me N1 man

Haha, I was thinking about it, but I was thinking you may have just been citizen.

NoodleLick wrote:
lucky333123 wrote:For everyone to know, Noodle normally does play scummy. Our other mafia member was not even active...Noodle, you need to make sure to check the mafia chat more often. I'm sorry that this game wasn't that fun for everyone after the first night. BG and vet got extremely lucky.

Anyway, does anyone have an improvements/comments to say?

You're an idiot, I do check the mafia chat often. But I ignored what you said, it was a freaking 1/11 chat to be hit by a bodyguard, and who in their right mind would guard TrueGent anyways?

Very unlucky with BG but there could have been a lookout on True. True is well-experienced player that most know, thus there could have been a lookout or Marshal on True.

HalkInHunt wrote:Should consider system change after 2 town wins on this set up?
lucky333123 wrote:For everyone to know, Noodle normally does play scummy. Our other mafia member was not even active...Noodle, you need to make sure to check the mafia chat more often. I'm sorry that this game wasn't that fun for everyone after the first night. BG and vet got extremely lucky.

Anyway, does anyone have an improvements/comments to say?

When you vote a mafia member(also buss) as a sheep on someone don't be the first guy to unvote him
Also voting after others isn't the best strategy

Ah thank you! I'll keep that in mind if I ever get a scum role again.

OllyRenard wrote:
lucky333123 wrote:For everyone to know, Noodle normally does play scummy. Our other mafia member was not even active...Noodle, you need to make sure to check the mafia chat more often. I'm sorry that this game wasn't that fun for everyone after the first night. BG and vet got extremely lucky.

Anyway, does anyone have an improvements/comments to say?

You did really good from my perspective, I think you still deserve some praise, especially with what you had to deal with

Thank you!

For everyone to know, Noodle normally does play scummy. Our other mafia member was not even active...Noodle, you need to make sure to check the mafia chat more often. I'm sorry that this game wasn't that fun for everyone after the first night. BG and vet got extremely lucky.

Anyway, does anyone have an improvements/comments to say?

HalkInHunt wrote:
lucky333123 wrote:
HalkInHunt wrote:So lucky who do you think is the scum between xUltiix/awesome

Between xUltiix and awesome, I feel like xUltiix has the highest probability of being scum but there are a few posts from awesome that seemed more scummish but they may have been a newbie mistake.

I don't care if I get lynched or not. Us,townies have already won.

/vote xUltiix

Now because of you we need to wait another two nights to see the flip
thanks......
/Vote Gent's plan
Hopefully Rhaz forgives use

I didn't pay attention to the others posts, sorry.

/vote Gent's plan

HalkInHunt wrote:So lucky who do you think is the scum between xUltiix/awesome

Between xUltiix and awesome, I feel like xUltiix has the highest probability of being scum but there are a few posts from awesome that seemed more scummish but they may have been a newbie mistake.

I don't care if I get lynched or not. Us,townies have already won.

/vote xUltiix

HalkInHunt wrote:
OllyRenard wrote:
HalkInHunt wrote:
OllyRenard wrote:Duffster/Jacko is town, my best bet is that awesome/Utlix is mafia. Maybe I'm being biased, but I see lucky as the most townie of the cit claims

I can find so many scummy things lucky have done but my role card which i just created says to not

No please do, if you really can't then I'll just go through their individual Isos

You get it that it's a 100% town win yea?

I agree, us townies have already won. I know that I am citizen.

OllyRenard wrote:
MichaelgRook wrote:To be honest, I was afraid of going alert and killing a town, good thing I didn't let the fear overwhelm the fear of dying or getting visited by a consig.

You got lucky with killing Consigliere and we are glad you did, because it let us be able to close this game up

I agree. I'm super glad that you went on alert because got rid of the Consig, so now we only have one mafia member left.

xUltiix wrote:
HalkInHunt wrote:So we have one scum between lucky/awesome/xUltiix
Can we make it appear like it interesting? i mean the scum from you try to appear like town and lynch the other ones, think like it's LYLO and you win if you lynch townie
I know it's won't happen and you will lose the game anyway but your gonna have a better feeling about that you could hunt the scum/appear like town
Fine for you guys? normal day of scum reading with no plans

I think last scum is awesome5000. I saw him lurking earlier while I was on the main page before going to Role Ideas and he did not vote on the plan.

He did post.

P-1: Got ninaj'ed

Plan 1 looks good to me.

Duffster came on earlier but never said anything...

/vote Plan 1

xUltiix wrote:
lucky333123 wrote:
moonbird wrote:yeah there's no good way to make a plan until the last two people claim

I hope they come online, but Duffster most likely will be replaced, so I suggest we wait for Micheal.

I am up for the plan to lynch moon, then Duffster. After that, we will need to decide what to do next.

I know what we will do next.

We will add to our signatures

NFM34 | Town | Won

because they are the last 2 scum

Yep! I see Duffster as scum mainly because of his non-explanation for voting. He only has 3 posts.

I know that I am a townie. I tried to hint to everyone early on I was citizen when I got upset at STAA, but I don't think anyone picked up on it.

moonbird wrote:yeah there's no good way to make a plan until the last two people claim

I hope they come online, but Duffster most likely will be replaced, so I suggest we wait for Micheal.

I am up for the plan to lynch moon, then Duffster. After that, we will need to decide what to do next.

xUltiix wrote:
xUltiix wrote:I think we should go ahead and lynch Moon.

*As soon as either Duffster or Michael have checked in.

I hope that one of them will check in. Most likely Michael will check in since he is the more active out of the two.

awesome5000 wrote:yeah
wait for duffster/michael
make everyone claim

has ladd claimed veteran yet?

ladd hasn't claimed anything yet.

HalkInHunt wrote:
OllyRenard wrote:It would make sense for moonbird to be framed out of everyone here, I give it that

Only one more Citizen claim to fit in and I have a pretty good guess on who Vet is

Lucky?

I'm Citizen. I tried to soft it earlier, not sure if anyone picked up on that.

So far:

lucky333123 - Slept peacefully
xUltiix - Slept peacefully
HalkInHunt - Slept peacefully
awesome5000
Moonbird
OllyRenard - Slept peacefully
MichaelgRook
TheDuffster
ladd
TrueGent - Bodyguard fought off Mafia

I believe I got everything.

HalkInHunt wrote:(HalkInHunt, TrueGent)
(OllyRenard, xUltiix, lucky333123)-Lock/Medium Town
(awesome5000)-Slight Town
(Ladd, TheDuffster, MichaelgRook)-Null/Slight scum
(Moonbird)-Scum

And yes when we have only one scum left we should mass claim

I agree with this too.

TheDuffster wrote:
STAA wrote:If Moon flips Town, we lynch Ladd and Gent.

lucky333123 wrote:
TheDuffster wrote:/unvote
/vote moon

What is your reasoning for voting Moon?

I feel like Duffster is more scum than Moon, mainly because Duffster has almost no posts. Two of the posts are just voting posts and the third post doesn't really make sense for their vote (not like STAA made any sense to begin with).

HalkInHunt wrote:Have JDSM posted anything?

He never posted in the thread. He was a substitute for Jarence23 who never posted.

/vote moonbird

Halk, you bring up a good point. Noodle may have been bussing, but Noodle has always been sheepish/comes across as scum in all the games I've played.

Moon is mainly Null for me.

I don't really like how Moon keeps on pushing against True. It still makes me feel like she is trying to mislynch. There is a possibility of True being arson, but at least we can rule out True being mafia.

Spoiler:

lucky333123 wrote:
ladd wrote:
lucky333123 wrote:Moon,

Please post and give a defense. I would vote you for reasons I stated in a previous post combined with things others points out, but it will put you at L-1. I don't want a quick hammer without giving you a chance to defend yourself.

You said you had Moon as Slight Town, what reasons do you mean?

I have Moon Null/Slight Town but leaning more towards Null.

Out of all of Moon's posts so far, I feel like this one is the most town oriented minus a few parts.

moonbird wrote:I disliked the basis of your scum read because it's so personalized and doesn't account for any other player's interactions with ladd thusfar. Forum mafia isn't about just your interactions with one player, because that can be influenced by personal sentiments. It's about the holistic set of interactions. That being said, it isn't particularly AI; it could be town not bothering to manufacture a whole read and instead lazily cherry-picking interactions or scum, and that's what I said.

My point is about Ladd is that you went from a high-risk push, so to say, to a very, very low-risk push: noodle. He gave a response which easily devalued your push, and you just dropped it cold, like you knew it was to fail. And the ease of which people have sheeped it, for whatever reason--they can't all be scum; just look at the numbers and exactly who is voting Noodle and for what reasons--makes the Noodle lynch feel like a ml to me. I don't expect this playerlist to bus this easily.

I don't know who the hell would be in your scumteam at this point in time; that hasn't been a consideration thusfar. All the players on that wagon could be town: it's happened many a time on this forum, and many a time in games that I've been in.

Noddle never said the lynch was bad. He said:
NoodleLick wrote:Are people seriously random voting Ladd already?

This reads as someone who's apathy or ability to read the game is appalling. From what I'm gathering, this is typical of Noodle. Therefore, it's NAI.

In this post, I do like that Moon points out that we went from Ladd to Noodle and that Noodle most likely didn't really read the thread. That is the only thing I like about this post.

Almost all the other posts seem neutral except for the one post that seemed to be targeted at True. That one post seemed to me that she was trying to choose another target to try and get everyone to focus on. True is usually somewhat inactive or at least was in the other game I was in, thus I feel like she could have been possibly trying to get a mislynch. I would really like a better explanation from her aside from "You're only this fucking lazy when you're scum."

This is why she is now leaning more Null.

moonbird wrote:@lucky33 Mostly voted Gent because it's getting old, and he knows I'm right. Fenciness on STAA point was valid from Gent; really couldn't figure out where i was going with that read when digging through their ISO. Ladd's point about self-projection stems from me playing more than a few games of mafia recently. Still trying to kick the habit of just reading like two ISOs and bullshitting whatever push I want from them. Reading myself as a Mroz waller rather than a FML waller from my ISO. It's an issue. Still disliking halk; the fact that they've pulled off me doesn't ring right.

gtg

TrueGent wrote:/vote moon

Why moon?

Good job Varanus and nice job vet!

I slept peacefully.

I'm doing this with my phone and trying to edit huge quote walls, so forgive me for any BBCode mistakes or spelling errors.

Varanus wrote:[spoiler]
OllyRenard wrote:I suppose I'll request protection tonight

Best of luck to you
HalkInHunt wrote:
lucky333123 wrote:Hello everyone!

/vote OllyRenard

I think they rolled town actually

This is an okay post
lucky333123 wrote:
HalkInHunt wrote:
lucky333123 wrote:Hello everyone!

/vote OllyRenard

I think they rolled town actually

Hmmm you bring a good point. I didn't think of that way.

/unvote

/vote Ladd

Oh
Okay
I will give you one scummer point, because this is just a weird exchange.

When I voted Olly that early in the game, I didn't really read the thread. I should have read everything. My vote on ladd was simply just because of his one word response/only voting responses. It was still just a random vote.

My explanation for my vote on Olly was explained here:

lucky333123 wrote:
ladd wrote:
lucky333123 wrote:
Hmmm you bring a good point. I didn't think of that way.

?

OllyRenard wrote:I suppose I'll request protection tonight

I wasn't thinking when I voted him/her. I just choose someone random from the list. I should have paid attention to posts. I'm now assuming Olly is claiming a PR role of some sort due to his post.

Varanus wrote:
lucky333123 wrote:
HalkInHunt wrote:So
What do you guys think about claiming doused?

These are pros and cons that I could think of:

Pros: We can eliminate those who claim from being arsonist
Mafia member could be doused thus if arson ignites, it will be one less mafia member in the game.
Cons: If someone dies before claim, arson could claim being doused but they would not be able to ignite anytime soon.
Mafia will know who doused victims, thus could kill non-doused victims.

I don't understand the second pro
Last I checked, they'd still die from the ignition if they claimed
I also don't see why Arso would fake claim doused from an opening, unless the plan was to only ignite once in the game
TrueGent wrote:
lucky333123 wrote:Hey True! How are you?

Dude I'm good

Not claiming doused is interesting, it really depends on whether or not we think we effectively Arson hunt, sincle not claiming doused really only helps us in the early game

More or less this type of thing. Probably end up claiming everything by D4.

Even though mafia would still die if they claim doused, we could possibly find a push on someone because mafia believes or knows that they are arson. Thus if that person flips to be arson, we could figure out if that other person is a likely candidate for mafia. Hopefully my wording makes sense.

Varanus wrote:Then just big moon
STAA dies now

What does big mean?

I honestly have no idea what to make of STAA other than he is annoying/super contradictory/doesn't care what-so-ever to help us townies. STAA doesn't seem like town because of his posts in general, so I have him right now as Slight scum/Null. If there was a jester in this game, he would automatically nominated to the position. Moon is still more Null than anything else for me as I stated earlier, but I am willing to vote Moon.

I will be replying to the thread when I can get on my computer since I need to do a few response to quotes, but I can't edit easily on my phone.

awesome5000 wrote:Who exactly is Varanus?

In my opinion, an experienced FMer that is well-known. I know him from another game.

moonbird wrote:diobot

?

Town of Salem Game Forums

Search found 56 matches

Re: [Newcomer FM] NFM 34 | Game over | That was dumb

Re: [Newcomer FM] NFM 34 | Game over | That was dumb

Re: [Newcomer FM] NFM 34 | Game over | That was dumb

Re: [Newcomer FM] NFM 34 | Game over | That was dumb

Re: [Newcomer FM] NFM 34 | Game over | That was dumb

Re: [Newcomer FM] NFM 34 | Day 3 | C O M E A T M E

Re: [Newcomer FM] NFM 34 | Day 3 | C O M E A T M E

Re: [Newcomer FM] NFM 34 | Day 3 | C O M E A T M E

Re: [Newcomer FM] NFM 34 | Day 3 | C O M E A T M E

Re: [Newcomer FM] NFM 34 | Day 3 | C O M E A T M E

Re: [Newcomer FM] NFM 34 | Day 2 | The search

Re: [Newcomer FM] NFM 34 | Day 2 | The search

Re: [Newcomer FM] NFM 34 | Day 2 | The search

Re: [Newcomer FM] NFM 34 | Day 2 | The search

Re: [Newcomer FM] NFM 34 | Day 2 | The search

Re: [Newcomer FM] NFM 34 | Day 2 | The search

Re: [Newcomer FM] NFM 34 | Day 2 | The search

Re: [Newcomer FM] NFM 34 | Day 2 | The search

Re: [Newcomer FM] NFM 34 | Day 2 | The search

Re: [Newcomer FM] NFM 34 | Day 2 | The search

Re: [Newcomer FM] NFM 34 | Day 2 | The search

Re: [Newcomer FM] NFM 34 | Night 1 | Organ Donation

Re: [Newcomer FM] NFM 34 | Day 1 | The Other White Meat

Re: [Newcomer FM] NFM 34 | Day 1 | The Other White Meat

Re: [Newcomer FM] NFM 34 | Day 1 | The Other White Meat