Town of Salem Game Forums

verdance wrote:

K1llthestory wrote:fml should have won and verdance and milte need to be blacklisted

i dont think you understand it was unwinnable for mafia

arguably better to take a chance in a kingmaker situation although still similarly dire

You don't understand that you should never give up if there is a chance to win. I needed to convince K1ll that I am innocent. That was all.

FMLSheWas12 wrote:I meant the rationality behind not killing.

Why you killed Mafia in the first place? It never helps you.

Exacerbated wrote:

kosmo16 wrote:I am heartbroken. That's all I have to say.

I think you played decently. You made very good decisions; push your partner's lynch half-heartedly to set up shade on literally everyone who voted gabby, tie yourself to gabby to make her look bad. The only thing that you could have done better was sell the disguise. Which I think you will learn after playing more FM.

I had a plan for the rest of the game. But when 2nd post of your teammate on mafia chat is

verdance wrote:ok we l o s t lol

you start to regret that milte was replaced.

I am heartbroken. That's all I have to say.

verdance wrote:so apparently he was trying to bus me into a 1% chance of victory with a doctor jailkeeper and tracker left alive and thought that refusing to communicate at all in the mafia chat was the best strat in case i object

ah of course why didnt i see that before

1% > 0%
Please, remember about that when you consider to do such a play next time.

Why you threaten me Ice? I made my choice. I hope it is a good one.
/vote K1ll

These are my reads:
moon
Ice
K1ll/Jord

FML
Verdance

K1ll/Jord

TeamMystic wrote:/unvote

Dont fucking hammer

Believe me If I planned to hammer, I would just do that. Remember an advice of a chess master:

The threat is stronger than the execution

FMLSheWas12 wrote:

kosmo16 wrote:I think I will just hammer FML. I have no idea what is going on. Are you guys on drugs?

This is actually mafia.

Interesting you say that. Actually, you are Mafia along with verdance, no quick hammer on you at the beginning of the day make sense now. So, the choice for SK is between K1ll and Jord. You think it is K1ll.

I think I will just hammer FML. I have no idea what is going on. Are you guys on drugs?

TeamMystic wrote:

Santa07 wrote:verdance is replacing milte

Anything is better than milte I guess

It wasn't nice.

FMLSheWas12 wrote:

ICECLIMBERS wrote:But it is not Kosmo.

I hope you didn't believe me when I said Jord and I were mafia.

tbh, I will need to check if "jokes" are in your Town meta. I played with you few times when you were a Town member and can't recall such a behavior.

FMLSheWas12 wrote:Maybe Jord and I are mafia that know kosmo is the serial killer. :0

Then I would need a Bayonet, because was rb'd last night.

SK either was forced to kill Recruiter (K1ll) or wanted to frame K1ll.

If we assume that SK killed Town Investigative roles, because was worried about being investigated then it is between FML, Jord and K1ll.

FMLSheWas12 wrote:kosmo what would it take for you to hammer me right now? :^)

I must read the thread. I am sick, so will do it when I feel better.

K1llthestory wrote:also im a stupid invest

it is a NIGHT ACTION. not a day action. that means i have to wait a night before the action takes place. that means last night was supposed to be my exa jail. i submitted a jail on kosmo tonight.

You shouldn't reveal who will be jailed. There was a chance that I will be attacked at night.

TeamMystic wrote:Kosmo according to your logic it was a bad move for me to watch Gobln because he couldn't have killed been possessed. Now you've just told me he had a chance to be deserter but never mentioned this before.

This tells me you knew Gobln was not a deserter

You really want to find anything to prove I am scum. As I said each player had the same chance for being deserter, so you can ignore this fact in calculations.

TeamMystic wrote:You realize the chance of finding a possessed killing is lower than finding a deserter killing as a Tracker right?

Yes, but you add up chances. Transporter had 0% chance to be a possessed who will kill and 10% to be a deserter. Chance for being deserter is for each player the same.

TeamMystic wrote:Kosmo
Deserter is a killer

The chance for each player for being deserter is the same. The chance that the player is possessed and will do a factional kill is different for each role. I won't try to explain you Math.

TeamMystic wrote:

kosmo16 wrote:

TeamMystic wrote:Kosmo why are you so obsessed with me watching a Transporter. I don't really get why you feel it's such a bad decision

Your objective was to find a killer. I can assure you that if GobIn were possessed he would never do a factional kill.

This logic is false, and I love how you excluded the possibility of him being Deserter

I didn't. You just want to increase a probability to find a killer so you are aiming for possessed not for deserter.
I will tell you how I would choose who to watch. I would take into account all combinations of three roles (165) and for each I would pick a role which most likely would be sent to kill someone. The role with a highest score would be a person to watch. If you want to do that now you will have only 21 combinations.

TeamMystic wrote:Kosmo why are you so obsessed with me watching a Transporter. I don't really get why you feel it's such a bad decision

Your objective was to find a killer. I can assure you that if GobIn were possessed he would never do a factional kill.

There is a thing I really regret I didn't do Day 1. We didn't do a night plan and many people screwed up their night actions (Gabby, Jord, K1ll). It's a shame :/

NesMettaur wrote:

kosmo16 wrote:

moonbird wrote:Gabby, sorry if you've already said. Attempting to sort you and Kosmo here. What's your take on both Kosmo and Milte?

Gabby said she wont be here for the rest of day 2.

Why I push on Jord instead of milte? I was already attacked for wanting lynch milte? The problem is I don't know nothing about them. I guess you can't have a scumread or a townread on milte. I wish they were replaced.

You weren't attacked for wanting to lynch Milte (you weren't even alone on that opinion) but more because you kept trying to swing the discussion off of Gabby and onto Milte, and only came into the Gabby discussion once everyone seemed sure that Gabby was the day's lynch target and started suspecting you for deliberately ignoring it.

Hmm, you are right. I didn't share my opinion on Gabby earlier.

I have a question. What would you do as Inventor Night 1? For example I would give someone a Camouflage. For an evil it is useless for a Townie it is a blessing.

moonbird wrote:Gabby, sorry if you've already said. Attempting to sort you and Kosmo here. What's your take on both Kosmo and Milte?

Gabby said she wont be here for the rest of day 2.

Why I push on Jord instead of milte? I was already attacked for wanting lynch milte? The problem is I don't know nothing about them. I guess you can't have a scumread or a townread on milte. I wish they were replaced.