Town of Salem Game Forums

Asew54321 wrote:So basically nobody had any idea how the hell Shade worked, and me, being the noobiest person here (don't say that I'm not you dirty liar), had to be the LUCKY soul to get it. Seems legit.

Sounds like me when I rolled Relius Clover Neutral with no win con is always a fun place to be in and just cause chaos.

JackoDerp wrote:Hip doesn't seem to think there was a thought process to it.

There was a thought process and there was reading involved.
I think my investigation pool was something like dama/mihail/LoF/Elusive


I should've guessed that Elusive was scum, with their happy-go-lucky reaction And that the game didn't blow up immediately after being rolled
Still can't read the difference between Neutral and Town

My understanding of Shade was:

They track someone for a master every night
they want their killer to lose

Are you implying I'm not always happy go lucky? I usually am unless I'm arguing someone's trash logic or confidence

Asew54321 wrote:This was my first time being Shade. I had no idea what the hell I was doing. I think I was expected to know everything about Shade and Phantom (based on the conversation in the spectator chat). But I have to be on my a-game and know everything about everything before even thinking about playing Forum Mafia and stuff...

Still I played like an absolute noob. When the game started, I had no idea what was different between Phantom and Shade, and now that I know, I want to die.

Did you not see how many questions were asked on how Shade worked? Nobody understood it properly here basically so that's nothing to feel down on. Although I will add that it is nice to know now so that's a nice thing to learn from all this.

No reason to give up, c'est la vie. So is life, take from it. Learn from it and get better.
You learn from experience and you can take from that experience to get better learn to catch things you wouldn't catch before.

I completely tanked my first game as mafia and neutral and got better from there

Kirize12 wrote:Asew, it wasn't your fault, it was mine. I single handedly lost the game for lyfacrion just like I always do when I'm allowed to live until lategame.

Didn't really do anything wrong aside from being paranoid which isn't that big of an issue, we were in a tough place from the get go so we were on a steep climb and did a moderately good job if you ask me.

To be fair your information wouldn't have been that helpful in late game anyways and all the claims were out pretty quickly, or at least the ones that mattered in the long run so catching the lie wouldn't have changed much.

What really sunk our ship was Mihail getting caught immediately, Jammy then getting caught right after, and then not killing Schultz when had the chance.

At the time was thinking of blocking the Town protective since we thought it was you and not LoF, should have just gone for it but what's done is done.

I'd rather just Jacko be on my team dammit

Of course not, how do you get better by quitting?
I mean I cant say I'm the best, just ask Arc

To be fair I wanted to kill Schultz but Kirize didn't trust me about them blocking Ultz and didn't want to burn, should have gone for it anyways.

So he noticed just didn't get why I was lying.... rip that. C'est la vie again

Should have been more upfront with the Shade, turns out really strong obvious hints don't work

It was just bad decisions all around and bad luck more than anything. C'est la vie and move on

The claim was likely belief that it was from Schultz, the claim was unnecessary but needed to claim role blocked at the least. Didn't expect it to come from the Kelpto.

I would have given up already the night before pretty much but that was too amusing to stop, watching that go was a pretty good highlight of the game

@Chit
I was banking on Jacko checking me as I was a key target pretty much the entire time once it came down to PoE, the missed night check and then checking everyone else was clearly not expected
But for that night in question I had assumed you were town and LoF was scum

However what really messed us up was the role block on Kirize by you Chit, we were going for a retrained consort play so that the two role blocks would make sense on why one was missing from then on and we didn't attack anyone that night. The stealing from Cmitc ruined that plan

Gg

I blame a lot of things and bad luck, c'est la vie. Did decently well all things considered and we only figured out LoF was legit after blocking my kill. Was a nice saving grace there
Wouldn't have been needed if Kirize listened to me though but what can you do. Gg Jacko despite being prodded and only finding mihail basically.

We knew you were sit, Halk was checked by Mihail N1. Went nowhere at best you could be NE.

Also I also blame Asew for not realizing I intentionally lied about their results to tell them I was scum and think about why I told them to come back to me.

With short's vote didn't I hammer?

I blame Jammy and Kirize

Jammy for not claiming role blocked
And Kirize for not trusting me that Schultz would block Ult when I had the chance to kill Schultz.

Also, still not on Jacko's team 2017! New year same memes

LoF is, honestly that should have been obvious with the Trauma patient claim

/Vote Elusive

Honestly I'd drag this out more just for the fun of it because it's funny but I'm busy today and just want it to be over now.

Was that to me? Honestly I don't trust LoF worth a lick, ICE is still sketchy but ICE at least has logic behind it and LoF is a bunch of wut

Seem to entirely neglect the fact that if mafia is not blocked Schultz gets killed because Klepto can potentially use Cmitc still which kills the rest of your plan of PoE anyways

Neigh, I did not have the shade. Although the logic is a lot of Wifom there LoF. Why would this do that is a pretty weak argument.

Then why wait so long to check me?