Guilty Votes

[CAPTAINPHASMA123]

Watch for people who didn't vote up a Mafia to stand but voted Guilty. The chances are they are a Mafia member. Been doing this and I usually catch Mafia members.

[SpellChecker]

Sometimes this is a good strategy when mafia does not vote, most of the time I end up getting them as vigilante.

[chitownmvp01]

Watch for people who didn't vote up a Mafia to stand but voted Guilty. The chances are they are a Mafia member. Been doing this and I usually catch Mafia members.

Correct. When looking for Mafia in non-voters, it's usually the ones who don't vote in the Voting Phase, Judgement Phase not as much, abstainers/innocent voters could still be Mafia. After a Mafia is lynched, I always check someone who didn't vote when I'm Invest/Sheriff.

[CAPTAINPHASMA123]

Anyone who didn't vote them up is suspicious. The ones that didn't and guilty are almost always scum. Innos are dumb town/jesters.

Yeah that's what I observed in playing many games.

[saladani]

I'd agree, but only if votes are slow. Fast votes don't give a chance for everyone to vote before the trial

[CAPTAINPHASMA123]

I'd agree, but only if votes are slow. Fast votes don't give a chance for everyone to vote before the trial

Yeah. I also agree with you. Slow or mediocre votes are probably scum.

[AspieKairy]

I'd agree, but only if votes are slow. Fast votes don't give a chance for everyone to vote before the trial

True.

I look at voting patterns to weed out scum, but if the votes come in so quickly or there are whisper games going on and 3/4 of the town has no clue why someone is being voted up, it gets harder.

Granted, the new patch will do away with Mayor Games and make people less eager to participate in a whisper game until they know there's no Blackmailer who can hear them...but people who are brought back by a Ret sometimes demand roles in whispers and then will start voting someone up without telling the rest of the town why.

[Deldris]

I'd agree, but only if votes are slow. Fast votes don't give a chance for everyone to vote before the trial

True.

I look at voting patterns to weed out scum, but if the votes come in so quickly or there are whisper games going on and 3/4 of the town has no clue why someone is being voted up, it gets harder.

Granted, the new patch will do away with Mayor Games and make people less eager to participate in a whisper game until they know there's no Blackmailer who can hear them...but people who are brought back by a Ret sometimes demand roles in whispers and then will start voting someone up without telling the rest of the town why.

If it's someone who whispered then I always assume it's just for time. If they didn't whisper then I'll demand a role and will from them.

[darkabsol]

Don't vote them up and don't vote, that way no one can accuse you of anything.

[chitownmvp01]

Anyone who didn't vote them up is suspicious. The ones that didn't and guilty are almost always scum. Innos are dumb town/jesters.

Add dumb Mafia to the innos. Mafia seem to vote inno more often when it gets later in the game, even though they don't have majority yet. I've seen Mafia think that voting inno will work when voting guilty would have kept them unexposed and allow them to reach majority.

Don't vote them up and don't vote, that way no one can accuse you of anything.

We've been talking about accusing people who didn't vote.

[darkabsol]

Anyone who didn't vote them up is suspicious. The ones that didn't and guilty are almost always scum. Innos are dumb town/jesters.

Add dumb Mafia to the innos. Mafia seem to vote inno more often when it gets later in the game, even though they don't have majority yet. I've seen Mafia think that voting inno will work when voting guilty would have kept them unexposed and allow them to reach majority.

Don't vote them up and don't vote, that way no one can accuse you of anything.

We've been talking about accusing people who didn't vote.

I probably should've explained that better… but right now I can't be bothered. Eh.