Role Ideas (Currently Fifteen-Added Glassblower to improve.)

[TheBlitzBarker]

This is what I believe to be called a, what you say? Bump.

[EyeopenerLooking]

Please review the Boxer and the Spider please. Thank you.

I like the Box so is Mafia able to kill him when boxing? Is GF able to kill him like SK?
Is he able to kill weaker Mafia? What do you mean? "You can make a vague guess at the role by their strength during the match".
Will Spider be told the roles of the people in IT'S web OR get hints like Investigator?
These are REAL questions.

GF and Mafioso should be able to kill Boxer.All other Mafia should be killed.
Boxer should be able to kill Lookout,Medium,and Retributionist to. For other Town It will Say something like your target fought fair.
For Witch,Survivor,and Executioner It will say your target fought dirty.

[TheBlitzBarker]

Please review the Boxer and the Spider please. Thank you.

I like the Box so is Mafia able to kill him when boxing? Is GF able to kill him like SK?
Is he able to kill weaker Mafia? What do you mean? "You can make a vague guess at the role by their strength during the match".
Will Spider be told the roles of the people in IT'S web OR get hints like Investigator?
These are REAL questions.

GF and Mafioso should be able to kill Boxer.All other Mafia should be killed.
Boxer should be able to kill Lookout,Medium,and Retributionist to. For other Town It will Say something like your target fought fair.
For Witch,Survivor,and Executioner It will say your target fought dirty.

First of all, I never said the Boxer is night immune. Second I never said the Spider learned anything about other roles. Finally, I don't think that too many should be able to be killed by the boxer due to various reasons, especially since all you suggested are town.

[EyeopenerLooking]

Now I get it.
I think I wrote this when I was tired.
Sorry for that.

[Feallike]

These are good ideas!!

I mean they have there bugs and glitches. (Witch doctor seems a little OP since it kills its target even when the witch doctor is killed)

Other then some minor bugs i find these ideas very good. GOod work!

[TheBlitzBarker]

These are good ideas!!

I mean they have there bugs and glitches. (Witch doctor seems a little OP since it kills its target even when the witch doctor is killed)

Other then some minor bugs i find these ideas very good. GOod work!

Thanks and...think about it, you're a witchdoctor killed almost at the very beginning of the game...you want revenge for sure.

[OriginalTraps]

Hunter

Has the ability to follow where someone goes at night, without being detected by a lookout ( he's is a townie trust builder )
Cannot be transported, Hidden, ( He's silent at night, this prevents being transported and accidentally killed, plus the transporter can trust you) - a message pops up to the transporter, Your target was hidden, you could not find him.
some abilty balancing may include.... The hunter is looking for bragging rights, if he finds 2 bad guys, then he retires. OR
only allowed to follow 1 person per game, but lay 2 traps outside a persons house ( so if they leave their house, they die, or anyone visiting also dies, however if a townie dies, then the hunter leaves town forever the following day. OR and this is the last thing I could think of,
He is allowed to follow asymany people as he wants at night, but as soon as he follows a neutral roll, since they are unpredictable, he makes the mistake of also being caught. therefor if he follows a jester, then their will be chaos.

I'm no game dev tho, Im just a HUGE fan who is definitely going to support the game when the update come out tomorrow or today

[TheBlitzBarker]

Hunter

Has the ability to follow where someone goes at night, without being detected by a lookout ( he's is a townie trust builder )
Cannot be transported, Hidden, ( He's silent at night, this prevents being transported and accidentally killed, plus the transporter can trust you) - a message pops up to the transporter, Your target was hidden, you could not find him.
some abilty balancing may include.... The hunter is looking for bragging rights, if he finds 2 bad guys, then he retires. OR
only allowed to follow 1 person per game, but lay 2 traps outside a persons house ( so if they leave their house, they die, or anyone visiting also dies, however if a townie dies, then the hunter leaves town forever the following day. OR and this is the last thing I could think of,
He is allowed to follow asymany people as he wants at night, but as soon as he follows a neutral roll, since they are unpredictable, he makes the mistake of also being caught. therefor if he follows a jester, then their will be chaos.

I'm no game dev tho, Im just a HUGE fan who is definitely going to support the game when the update come out tomorrow or today

Yeah...I support it as much as I can as well...but you know...what do you think of my ideas? (Although I quite like you're concept there)

[TheBlitzBarker]

for boxer what happens when you box a mafia?

Depends, if its Mafioso or Godfather you'll find that they have greater skills than you. Other mafia are weaker, but are still somewhat skilled.

[TheBlitzBarker]

I guess...this is...what you guys call a...um...bump?

[TheBlitzBarker]

I guess...this is...what you guys call a...um...bump?

Again since it changed forums.

[TheBlitzBarker]

Hm. Cool ideas but the Encoder seems like a nerfed Janitor.

Please refer to earlier comments by others, and the replies I gave them.

[TheBlitzBarker]

Added Paranoid, please criticize very hard on me.

[TheBlitzBarker]

Hm. Cool ideas but the Encoder seems like a nerfed Janitor.

Please refer to earlier comments by others, and the replies I gave them.

Dude I dont see the other comments regarding the encoder. Alls im saying is it seems pointless. Your other ones are fine, if not a little too creative. No need to get rude m8.

I wasn't rude, and please refer to page 2.

[EyeopenerLooking]

I like it.
It sounds fun.
Would you have to Select yourself at night or in the morning to make an announcement?

[TheBlitzBarker]

I like it.
It sounds fun.
Would you have to Select yourself at night or in the morning to make an announcement?

...night

[Santa07]

I'm guessing you copied the paranoid from epicmafia's loudmouth? or is it just coincidence?

[TheBlitzBarker]

I'm guessing you copied the paranoid from epicmafia's loudmouth? or is it just coincidence?

Erm...who's that?

[Warpenguin55]

My Opinions here:
Burglar: Completely pointless as a Neutral.What is the point of having a neutral deception . Would probably work better with the Mafia.

Witch-doctor: Its a good role in theory, but i see 2 problems. Having the part with If killed at night, curses the killer will more then likely help the Town more then it would hurt it. My second issue is the fact if you are cursed you are guaranteed death. People would just quit because they cant be saved. But this is a pretty good role on paper.

Ripper: Would work better with the Mafia. Seeing as how it hurts 2 town roles, it would be a very powerful role for the Mafia to have.

Apothecary: Would overshadow the doctor too much.

Duelist: Would overshadow the Vigilante.

Boxer: Could we maybe have an example of the power you mentioned? Im currently in the middle on this one

Dragon: What if there already is a Mafioso? And turning on the godfather seems like a game throw TBH.

Encoder: Too Similar to the Janitor

Singer: Just No. Would be a boring role.

Spider: *Your, not You're. Too strange of a role. The ability to roleblock multiple people could really just prove as a frustration to the roleblocked, and the SK kills any roleblockers.

Paranoid: The vet is paranoid. This wouldn't work.

These are not meant as personal attacks on you, and if they come off as it then im sorry.

[Mandike13]

GOODLUCK BLITZ

[TheBlitzBarker]

GOODLUCK BLITZ

[TwitchCattz]

I like the ideas, and hope to see at least one or two added to the game.

[TheBlitzBarker]

I like the ideas, and hope to see at least one or two added to the game.

Glad to hear it.

[TheBlitzBarker]

In reply to Warpenguin55.

Spoiler: 1. Burglar is called Neutral Deception because one of my earlier viewers called it that, and I though "Eh, why not."
2. Witchdoctor: There's always a risk that a non-town could kill him, but there are still jailors and vigilantes that might, its a risk, but most actual roles have risks. Now quitting because you're cursed? If its late enough in the game, you could still win, and if its early you still have a few nights to do something[.
3. Ripper:...I have no arguments, but I feel like this is something a person would do alone.
4. Apothecary: Sure, it overshadows, but if there's no doctor it could be very useful...or they could get killed since they can't protect themself. Also, his ability can only be used a little late in the game, and I never said how often he can use it (I should probably put that down...its "once" in case you wanted to know.
5. Duelist: He wouldn't really overshadow, he's more like a clone almost, just a little different. And with the possibility of attacking a night immune or a townie, its likely he wouldn't really "duel" to much.
6. Boxer: (Ex: Boxes with *insert name*. *Insert name seems to be quite skilled, they may be Bodyguard, Jailor, Veteran, or Mafioso.) He investigates by judging skill and if his opponent is a little too weak in fighting...they might die. And if their a little too strong *cough-cough evil* he dies.
7. Dragon: Maybe I'll put down that he kills that any Mafioso first night, taking his place? And Gamethrowing? No, in myth Dragons are greedy, he just wants to be the leader, even if he's the only one left.
8. Encoder: Maybe, but at least he does something. (I have no argument o-o)
9. Singer: First, there are plenty of regular roles that are boring, but just fit in the game enough that you can't get rid of them. Second, its basically a reverse Executioner, but can remove night immunities and can role block.
10. Spider: First, congratulations you realized it would be a frustration (sorry for the sarcasm), and second, the serial killer learns their identity, he's probably gonna kill 'em anyway.
11. Paranoid: This is used as a noun/title, and he acts completely different.
(Whew that was a handful to type...might as well put it as a spoiler.

[Mandike13]

Looking over the roles again. I really do like the dragon.