Two suggestions

[ObiWanCumnobi]

First, have retributionalist become medium once they've revived someone.

Second, make neutral killing immune to witch. So many times in ranked where witch messes up nk, or screws them over in the last few turns by siding with maf. Nk is already a hard enough role in ranked.

[Purple998]

1. Ret is already powerful enough.
2. Maybe, I don't really know.

[Jezz92]

1. No.
2. This sounds like someone who played NK and is salty over a witch fucking them over. Witch can screw mafia just as badly, hell even witch can make mafia kill their own team mates, does that mean the godfather and Mafioso should also be immune to the witch?

[DragoWhooves]

1) How about making them a Survivor with no vests?
2) No, witching the SK to kill your enemies is so useful, especially in coven, say someone who you know is town was jailed, and you know who the jailor is, you could make the SK attack the jailor and put sus on the townie

[Jezz92]

1) How about making them a Survivor with no vests?

Why would you change their alignment?

[DragoWhooves]

1) How about making them a Survivor with no vests?

Why would you change their alignment?

so they can't prove as town

[Shilster]

1) How about making them a Survivor with no vests?

Why would you change their alignment?

so they can't prove as town

That itself alters their wincon by being able to side with scum

[Jezz92]

1) How about making them a Survivor with no vests?

Why would you change their alignment?

so they can't prove as town

They can still claim to have revived the person and be confirmed via no cc

[lemonader666]

1. Never
2. Never

[Emberguard]

1) How about making them a Survivor with no vests?

Why would you change their alignment?

so they can't prove as town

They can still claim to have revived the person and be confirmed via no cc

Except why would they revive anyone in the first place if it's going to screw them over? That would simply make them more likely to lose as they could be killed the night they revive, plus any killers from any side could kill them at any time. It's not uncommon for vigs to either forget who is what or for scum to randomly choose a target including on confirmed survivors/witch

[Shilster]

Also, Jailors/Vigs will kill you right after you revive.

[Jezz92]

Exactly, so why even have it change alignment
I was responding to the person who suggested that

Ret is fine as is, it doesn't have to change its role at all after it revives