Town of Salem Game Forums

npromin1 wrote:

cxl1024 wrote:

DJVoxel wrote:I'm claiming PR


/Vote HappyMatt

Shit is about to hit the fan....again. lol

That means there's 2 liars. All 3 mafia members claimed a PR role.

DJVoxel wrote:

Sevohaseth wrote:

DJVoxel wrote:/vote HappyMatt

I'm just gonna go with my gut.

We will almost definitely be lynching HappyMatt at some point but the day does not end until mid-day Thursday so we are using this time to discuss. It's a perfect time for the new comers to catch up. So we're holding off actually voting to not accidentally end the day early.

Also, you're vote won't count unless you put it in bold.

Thank you.

/Lynch HappyMatt

Krazikitteh wrote:I slept in so I don't have much time this morning, and I have to try and get some reads done for my other game but I plan on popping on later if I can.

Out of what's left this is our current Pwr list. The * being one that doesn't fit.
Town Investigative - Lookout - Sevo
Town Support - Escort - jman
Town Killing - Expert
Random Town - Doc - npromin
Random Town - Moonbird
Random Town - Investigator - Wolf
*Investigative - Puma

People I believe to be telling the truth: Sevo, jman and Moonbird.
Sevo seemed generally confused and has explained the whole dealio. Now if Matt doesn't flip mafia then we have some things to check with Sevo.
jman I don't trust him because of his written reads, but rather his claim. No one else has CC the Town support slot so currently he is the only one that actually fits in it therefore unless one of the afks claims it, jman is telling the truth.

@notCalm. I'd say all pwr roles that have fully hardclaimed. Those who are staying vague remain that way.
Moonbird because he has been active helpful, and been a great asset to the Matt discussion. I don't think he's scum for not going in more detail about his role, since as I said before the last thing we want is Mafia and neutals to have a hit list.

npromin1 wrote:ok so we all agree Matt is lying in the PR bracket, but who do we think is the other liar (unless the random town is a citizen or someone afk claims a PR role)

We're basically unofficially voting on who is the scummiest out of: Me,sevo,expert,wolf,puma,jman, and moonbird.

/unofficially vote either wolf or jman

Unorthodox1337 wrote:1. Yes, I confirm that I am the citizen.

2. Right now, my suspicions are on Wolfy, notCalmYT, and obviously, MattHappy369. Of course, we'll lynch MattHappy369 D2 definitely, in the last 36 hours.
We have 1 extra PR claim, correct? If it's just 1, my suspicion on Wolfy is medium. If it's 2, my suspicion on Wolfy is high.
Why? His "soft-claim" on jman being a town. I believe that wolfy's advocation of jman being a town is oddly suspicious.
Did he declare his TI role?

3. I'd like your opinions on notCalmYT. His aggressiveness towards being accused of being scum is noteworthy. Also, his belief that by voting MattHappy369 earlier and reasoning that this is very unscum-like due to the possibility that MattHappy won't be lynched is extremely scummy to me. Furthermore, I don't think he has contributed information/discussion towards the chat. Therefore, he's likely an SK.

4. Did puma address the accusations against him of being a bomber? If I recall, it was because he was "intent" on declaring Matt as the vig. However, this is probably found to be false now that we've confirmed he was double-pranked. Will be going back to see the accusations against Puma being bomber are scummy.

5. Will be able to post my analysis on everyone in like 24-36 hours, and also my top 5 scum suspicions. Currently very busy with a final school project, but will be able to spare some hours going through the chat TMR.

In conclusion:
I'm citizen. Wolfy and notCalmYT are my suspects. One of those who accused Puma of being bomber is likely the actual bomber, or another scum. Currently busy; unable to go through the chat ATM but will post analysis and top 5 suspicions soon.

Also, to prevent "hammering"
/unvote MattHappy369

Sevohaseth wrote:If we didn't have viable lunch candidates, I'd be all for a policy lynch on notCalm.

Unorthodox1337 wrote:In my view, these are three scum:
Matt
Wolfy
notcalmYT

Order of killing:
Matt
notcalmYT
Wolfy

cxl1024 wrote:

npromin1 wrote:So I have a few questions:
1. Out of the citizen claims, who do you trust the least with their claim?
2. Other than Matt, who do you think are the other missing two mafia roles?
3. Who do you think is the serial killer?

1. NotCalmYT, he is pushing hard for a lynch. Matt seems scummy, but I feel as though Not might be a neutral trying to gain towncred.
2. Jman could be a consort. Coincidence that he happened to role block a dead player? People tend to do this sometimes. But he also could be escort. I believe him when he says he can role block, and I am more willing to believe he is escort. The other one is most likely an active player. I can't see mafia not trying to push a lynch on someone. My guess is this person is very experienced, too. I don't know who it could be though.
3. Don't know and won't know until we have a further lead. But you asking about who the sk is and trying to get people to focus on this other than mafia gives me bad vibes from you. Sorry, but as town, I am more worried about mafia than the sk. Yes, taking out the sk reduces the kills to one per night. But, unless we have a solid lead on who it is, the sk will fly under the radar. It'd be like trying to find a needle in a haystack right now. The reason it gives me bad vibes is because you could be the sk trying to make it look like you are not sk by asking about who the sk is. But, again it's just a weird feeling. I am more inclined to believe you to be a doctor, though. But if you want to know what I think, I'd say Not by the sk because of my first point.

This is all just speculation. I could be completely wrong for all I know.

HappyMatt369 wrote:I really need to be more active...
Anyway, we need to track down the neutrals as well.
Any ideas?

Unorthodox1337 wrote:

Sevohaseth wrote:@notCalmYT Can you explain, in your own words, why you decided to vote for HappyMatt?

notCalmYT is giving me the feeling of like acting like a sheep, and attempting to mirror a citizen.
I read him as a neutral IMO.

npromin1 wrote:

notCalmYT wrote:

Sevohaseth wrote:@notCalmYT Can you explain, in your own words, why you decided to vote for HappyMatt?

1) Hard claim d2 for a Vigilante with a Witch in game is absurdly stupid
2) He claimed right after someone asked him to. He wasn't even voted. Suspicious.
3) He then claimed he was witched, he shot someone who was healed and transported. While we have 2 people claiming Witched, I trust more Kitteh than him. If the "Witched" message is a prank, he wouldn't have shot anyone.

I'm too tired to read 20 pages of stuff I like lists, and I like em clear.

After reading my claim post, do you still think I'm aligned with Matt?

Sevohaseth wrote:@notCalmYT Can you explain, in your own words, why you decided to vote for HappyMatt?

expertnoob10 wrote:

notCalmYT wrote:

Krazikitteh wrote:

npromin1 wrote:

npromin1 wrote:

npromin1 wrote:I feel I just had to claim because if I started randomly accusing puma again, noone would believe me!

Seriously, either there were 2 doctors, or they were both lying.

Wait.

WAIT.


Was puma pranked into thinking they were attacked or did the prank include that puma was healed?

I believe it included that puma was healed. Since the full message if you think about it in ToS is:
"You were attacked but someone nursed you back to heath."

The prank must be the Witched message. I think moon has to be Transporter, if he's the last RT, right?

Town Investigative - TheWolfBuddy (Investigator claim)
Town Protective - Zero (Marshal, dead)
Town Support - jman (Escort claim, but noone claimed roleblocked)
Town Killing - HappyMatt (Vigilante claim, possibly controlled into attacking puma)
Random Town - puma (TI claim?)
Random Town - moonbird (RT claim, which can be only Transporter now)
Random Town - npromin (Doctor claim, possibly healed puma)
Then we have Sevoaseth claiming Lookout, expertnoob claiming Town Killing.
Citizen - KraziKitte (also claims witched)
Citizen - notCalmYT
Citizen - Mace
Citizen
Citizen
Citizen

Scum team is HappyMatt & npromin? Thoughts?

Everyone keeps forgetting to put me in the list...

Krazikitteh wrote:

npromin1 wrote:

npromin1 wrote:

npromin1 wrote:I feel I just had to claim because if I started randomly accusing puma again, noone would believe me!

Seriously, either there were 2 doctors, or they were both lying.

Wait.

WAIT.


Was puma pranked into thinking they were attacked or did the prank include that puma was healed?

I believe it included that puma was healed. Since the full message if you think about it in ToS is:
"You were attacked but someone nursed you back to heath."

npromin1 wrote:

notCalmYT wrote:I think Alex felt under accusation and tried to call you in to save his day. The fact that he was killed by SK was to throw suspicion at Wolf, not because he was actually susp of being Mafia.

Me solving the riddle is a way to have fun. At least I do something for this game that's not lurking/posting nonsense.

Anyways, I think we can agree that Wolf v Alex was TvS, and the fact that moon was called in by Alex is rather suspicious. Therefore, noone cares about your detailed opinion on it moon, I want to hear from others.

Well you're right about two things.

1. It's impossible to change moonbird's opinion.
2. Solving the riddle actually is fun. I think in step four when the godfather means to take out the tenths digit, he means the digit in the tenths place, or the 5.