Town of Salem Game Forums

jakob12341 wrote:

ObiWan wrote:@jakob I'm talking about the last day. You never voted for Macca. Yes, you did say you didn't believe his Marshal claim, but you did not push further than that.

jakob12341 wrote:Well town will figure it out once I'm dead that you were lieing

This is the post that says "I'm giving up."

You were trying, but you weren't fighting as hard as you should've, in my opinion. That is just my advice to you. Trying is always better. Also, I forgot to mention this. If you felt I screwed up with any night actions, you just have to message me and I can confirm what you sent into me.

ObiWan wrote:@jakob I'm talking about the last day. You never voted for Macca. Yes, you did say you didn't believe his Marshal claim, but you did not push further than that.

jakob12341 wrote:Well town will figure it out once I'm dead that you were lieing

This is the post that says "I'm giving up."

You were trying, but you weren't fighting as hard as you should've, in my opinion. That is just my advice to you. Trying is always better. Also, I forgot to mention this. If you felt I screwed up with any night actions, you just have to message me and I can confirm what you sent into me.

ObiWan wrote:Macca/Hark - I have to say, I'm very proud of you two. They discussed throughout the game, and that play at the end was awesome. Very well done guys. That is how being in the Mafia should always be, even if you do lose.

jakob - My advice to you would be that if you are being considered for a lynch, FIGHT harder to stay alive. Sometimes scum just give up, which looked like what you were doing. Also, not submitting a night action in this situation was a scummy thing to do, in my opinion. Even if you think a witch is going to control you, you should still submit one anyways.

Elusivebelle and Trusty - I believe you two were the most active town members in the game. I felt you did an awesome job keeping the game moving. Even though your reads weren't always on point (Which, that takes time and practice), you still did awesome job as town members.

E3 - I think you had good intentions when shooting Swords, but, in my opinion, it's best to save those bullets for someone confirmed or someone who every one agrees is most likely scum. While you died the same night, which was unfortunate, if you had lived, you would've lost your bullets. If you hadn't shot Swords, the Mafia would've been in a different situation at the end of the game.

kot - Pay more attention in the future to details. And consider all scenarios when submitting your night action. Also, don't act so "jestery," it made you look very scummy.

To the rest: Thank you for a great game. Hope to see you in the next one.

Neasans wrote:Dork's slot just screamed Citizen from my opinion. Though sometimes I end up seeing Citizens everywhere lol. He just didn't look like scum or a power role, I really don't know how else to explain.

IamTrusty wrote:The read on jakob was really hard to make, I thought he was escort for a while but with all the claims in and the marshall claim from maca when he had softed it day 1(or 2 dont remember) made me pretty confident that he was consort.

The lookout thing was a reaction test for Jakob but I fucked up by voting him waaaay too early. Should've just went to bed instead of posting. Lesson learned though no more voting before the last 24 hours of the day.

p-edit. no I was citizen was just a reaction test for you

IamTrusty wrote:fuuuuuuuck xD
I fucked up srry town ;-;
I voted super late when i was really tired, the moment i woke up and saw harkonnen's vote I knew I fucked up bigtime.
Literally closed the tab and ragequit lol.

GG (reading all the comments now)

Neasans wrote:People accusing you doesn't make them scum. OMGUS'ing is flawed in that sense most of the time. I didn't really read much else of this game, but keep that in mind. Anyone can have a wrong read.

Harkkonen (sorry i legit can't spell your name ;-;) and MaccaMania both popping up almost in sequence when jakob was voted was a bit indicative imo. The comments on the mela read being wrong and on jakob being "definitely" Consort actually looked a bit over the top from my perspective, but again, didn't read the full thing so it might be my misunderstanding.

IamTrusty wrote:[b]/vote harkonnen[b]
Not much to discuss, 100% obvious who the last two mafia are.

MaccaMania wrote:I didn't fake claim a roleblock. I WAS ROLEBLOCKED. I got a message saying "You were roleblocked last night!" Jakob, if you are really pushing on this "you said elusive was town and then they died" Then wow.
Firstly, Elusive died 2 nights after I said that.
Secondly, Elusive was a power role, and as stated before the mafia might have a consig and they might have found out that they were a doctor, so they killed them.
Thirdly, That was a day 2 read, which was mainly based off the shitposting on day 1.

IamTrusty wrote:

jakob12341 wrote:Well sure hope Obi didn't make a choice for me :/

wtf. dont question if he did it wrong CHECK YOUR MESSAGES.
Tell us who you targeted with your roleblock.
You slept peacefully!

MaccaMania wrote:AAAAAAAAAAH JAKOB!

I was roleblocked last night. Unless Jakob thought that it would be smart to roleblock a Marshal as an Escort, then he is Consort

So that means that 1 of the Citizen claimers is the other Random Town. Ugh. Hark seems more scummy than Trusty, so between the two of them I would say Trusty is probably the other random town.

But before I do anything, I want to hear Jakobs reasoning (if any) on why he roleblocked me. Still, unless there really was a Transporter and Obi forgot that they can't be in game, Jakob is a Consort.

ladd wrote:It's fine to get as much as possible from a Day, but when there is nothing left to discuss there is no point in dragging it out.

I would like to hear Mel's opinion on every player not confirmed left alive before ending the day, but after that we can end it, as far as I am concerned.