Search found 109 matches

Return to: Episode X | A Comedy of Errors | [Town Wins]

Re: Episode X | A Comedy of Errors | [Town Wins]

Jordarrian wrote:Huh, this thread is still unlocked. Might as well share something.

One day when night started I went to the Mafia Night Chat section and saw cmitc. I instantly ignored this because I thought I was being paranoid and he was reading mafia chats


Yeah, that's something that should probably be fixed. Might not be a 100% confirmation but its dangerous enough of a metagaming tool to be problematic.
by VucubCaquix
Mon Jul 25, 2016 6:16 pm
 
Forum: Game Threads
Topic: Episode X | A Comedy of Errors | [Town Wins]
Replies: 3681
Views: 140129

Re: Episode X | A Comedy of Errors | [Town Wins]

Swordsworth wrote:Tinfoil is a crazy/not-before-considered theory

like actually suspecting chubby when no one did


Parrot theory tho
best theory
by VucubCaquix
Wed Jul 06, 2016 9:03 pm
 
Forum: Game Threads
Topic: Episode X | A Comedy of Errors | [Town Wins]
Replies: 3681
Views: 140129

Re: Episode X | A Comedy of Errors | [Town Wins]

I don't know what a tinfoil is qq

Also can I has rainbow flair
by VucubCaquix
Wed Jul 06, 2016 8:43 pm
 
Forum: Game Threads
Topic: Episode X | A Comedy of Errors | [Town Wins]
Replies: 3681
Views: 140129

Re: Episode X | A Comedy of Errors | [Town Wins]

Swordsworth wrote:
ChubbyMooshroom9 wrote:
ElusiveBelle wrote:*It's

Grammar aside, you gave it a hell of a push Chubby. Killing Alzar instead of Retral and trying to frame yourself ended up backfiring. Probably would have been better off not trying to frame yourself and pushing the idea that mafia was trying to mislynch you

What I think I did wrong was kill Swords. He treated me like confirmed town and I really regretted killing him end of D2. I also regret killing hip partially. I could have possibly stalled for time and swapped hip from a me lynch to a Jord lynch.

All I know is that I'll never be the same/will die soon after this game.


Nah, Killing me was the best decision. Vucub's pressure tinfoils are right 100% of the time. If she flipped town, her theory was right.


I can't tell if sarcasm or not >.>
Tiltedcomedian wrote:I think people (including hippo herself) underrated hippo. Still can't get over how she correctly pinged me right down to the role and specific actions in the last game we had together.


Not a question of how good she is, its a question of whether or not she read the game whatsoever.

And now, Vucub does reads? IDK. Let's try this out. Its our new segment:

Bird pun post game thing thing

Spoiler: Ronit: You were doing pretty decent until mass claim time. A bit aggressive, but maybe that's just your way. Hopefully you learned a valuable lesson about not doing... that thing you did with the stuff. It was pretty fun arguing with you though.

Leyva45: Rip. This game was just unlucky for you. Would be interesting to see how you played if things hadn't happened the way they did. Not like you could've put up a better defense with what happened.

TiltedComedian: You were alright most of the time. Don't let Jordarrian get on your nerves so much. That pretty much destroyed your usefulness that one day. No worries about my lynch either. I did think you were the bomber for awhile >.>

Salense: You were good while you were alive. Mafia made a good decision killing you. Rip.

Santa07: Its the best I've seen you do in one of my games. Time zones are hard and all, but you managed to contribute.

Jordarrian: I think you've improved a lot tbh. Although your defenses seemed pretty bad, it was pretty easy to tell you were town. And you did help save our asses in the end.

ChubbyMooshroom9: You could've done a lot of things better, but your plan was alright. Letting cmit make the kill was obviously a bad idea, and you probably could've done better in the end, but overall you played well. Mafia MVP.

Retralmega: You did alright. I think you realize what your mistakes were in this game, but you did get an uneasy start having to replace Gobln. You did your job well as an investigator, and for that you get props. Not many people would've investigated Nelly, but you did, and I agree that it was probably a good idea at the time.

Datdownie: Poor doctor. I should've defended you and realized what was going on, but your defense really needed work. You should probably keep some organized notes of claims and reads if you aren't already, since your confusion seems to be what got you mislynched.

Jackoderp: You did a nice job as bomber. Probably would've won if the mafia didn't exist, but the moment Evil visited Retral, you were done for. I don't think you would've been caught unless someone investigated you.

Hippophant: Idk what happened, you weren't really here a lot of the time and you didn't read the thread when you were. Make sure you have time to commit to a game if your going to sign up, since I don't really think your a bad player in general.

Alzar: During your time alive, you were a good leader for the town. You did more than just sit back and get overpowered results that swept the game, so you deserve some credit for that.

ElusiveBelle: You were a good town leader, and played really well the entire time. Also thanks for clearing me, I was worried I would get mislynched >.>

EvilDeanius0: You did a nice job setting up Downie for a mislynch. Your scum play could've been a bit more active though. It wasn't bad, just inactive and a bit sheepy. If you had more of a presence you might have avoided an investigation for a night or two.

Nellyfox: You were a good town leader up until the end of the game. Even though people might remember the mislynches that happened in the last few days, you did do a good job in the earlier days.

Cmitc1: Same as Evil pretty much. It seems like you did a lot of good stuff in mafia chat though to help your team, if you had put that much effort into day posting people might have trusted you a lot more.

Swordsworth: Tbh you were a bit lazy this game. I've seen you play well, but this was not one of those times. Not much else I can remember from you.

Arckas NotcalmYT: Honestly your claim wasn't too bad, if it had been made under better circumstances. You played alright, but easy on the rage. Nobody likes a ragey rager.

Murat1996: You were a pretty good escort, and I think you deserve some credit for that at least. Your town play wasn't that bad either. The mafia actually considered killing you early, which is a good thing I guess?
by VucubCaquix
Wed Jul 06, 2016 8:37 pm
 
Forum: Game Threads
Topic: Episode X | A Comedy of Errors | [Town Wins]
Replies: 3681
Views: 140129

Re: Episode X | A Comedy of Errors | [Town Wins]

Meh. Episodes aren't all that special other than the flairs anyway.
by VucubCaquix
Wed Jul 06, 2016 6:01 pm
 
Forum: Game Threads
Topic: Episode X | A Comedy of Errors | [Town Wins]
Replies: 3681
Views: 140129

Re: Episode X | Day 9 | Xplore your Options

Are you serious right now? Me being mafia makes absolutely no sense if you would bother to try even a little bit. Here, I'll give you a freebie.

VucubCaquix wrote:
ChubbyMooshroom9 wrote:
VucubCaquix wrote:Risked what? You had no other options. Either get framed or get caught.

Shoot Retral.


Fair point. But considering murat was told to attempt to block a kill I wouldn't be surprised if you took that chance.

If not you, then Jordarrian is mostly likely. Maybe TC. Not Nelly. I don't think the mafia would have made 2 huge mistakes with Nelly as godfather. Two really strange things are pointing to different suspects. The first is the kill order, which points to Chubby, as I said. The second is that the mafia chose to perform a kill with a janitor who claimed cit and was not trusted whatsoever by the town. That points to Jord, and to a lesser extent TC, who would've been a small target that night. Its possible the mafia made this kill because they didn't want to risk losing a more trusted member because of a roleblock, but still.

Pool 2
Hippo
Swords

Pool 1:
Chubby
Jord
TC
Nelly
Vucub

Pool 1 lynched
Pool 2 killed
Pool 1 lynched
Pool 2 killed
Pool 1 lynched
Mafia wins

We have 3 lynches to get the godfather, and 5 suspects.


This post is practically gamethrowing for mafia. Can you explain why?

One of these 3 lynches has to be Chubby. You can't just say "well played if it is you but meh I'm not interested anymore" when there's a huge argument against Chubby. You're literally going to cut your chances of winning just because you're too lazy to think about what's happened so far this game.

Read my freaking arguments from today. I'm tired of being ignored in games because other people are too lazy and stubborn to look at different viewpoints. If you still think I should be one of our lynches fine, but at least think about the possibilities instead of leaving it all to chance.
by VucubCaquix
Sun Jul 03, 2016 2:12 pm
 
Forum: Game Threads
Topic: Episode X | A Comedy of Errors | [Town Wins]
Replies: 3681
Views: 140129

Re: Episode X | Day 9 | Xplore your Options

Just out of curiosity, Chubby, did you ever consider alerting when retral investigated you?
by VucubCaquix
Sat Jul 02, 2016 1:55 pm
 
Forum: Game Threads
Topic: Episode X | A Comedy of Errors | [Town Wins]
Replies: 3681
Views: 140129

Re: Episode X | Day 9 | Xplore your Options

ChubbyMooshroom9 wrote:
VucubCaquix wrote:Risked what? You had no other options. Either get framed or get caught.

Shoot Retral.


Fair point. But considering murat was told to attempt to block a kill I wouldn't be surprised if you took that chance.

If not you, then Jordarrian is mostly likely. Maybe TC. Not Nelly. I don't think the mafia would have made 2 huge mistakes with Nelly as godfather. Two really strange things are pointing to different suspects. The first is the kill order, which points to Chubby, as I said. The second is that the mafia chose to perform a kill with a janitor who claimed cit and was not trusted whatsoever by the town. That points to Jord, and to a lesser extent TC, who would've been a small target that night. Its possible the mafia made this kill because they didn't want to risk losing a more trusted member because of a roleblock, but still.

Pool 2
Hippo
Swords

Pool 1:
Chubby
Jord
TC
Nelly
Vucub

Pool 1 lynched
Pool 2 killed
Pool 1 lynched
Pool 2 killed
Pool 1 lynched
Mafia wins

We have 3 lynches to get the godfather, and 5 suspects.
by VucubCaquix
Sat Jul 02, 2016 11:43 am
 
Forum: Game Threads
Topic: Episode X | A Comedy of Errors | [Town Wins]
Replies: 3681
Views: 140129

Re: Episode X | Day 9 | Xplore your Options

Risked what? You had no other options. Either get framed or get caught.
by VucubCaquix
Fri Jul 01, 2016 8:32 pm
 
Forum: Game Threads
Topic: Episode X | A Comedy of Errors | [Town Wins]
Replies: 3681
Views: 140129

Re: Episode X | Day 9 | Xplore your Options

Jordarrian wrote:Hip, nelly literally cannot be Mafia at this point


Can you explain how? I said unlikely not impossible.
by VucubCaquix
Fri Jul 01, 2016 7:56 pm
 
Forum: Game Threads
Topic: Episode X | A Comedy of Errors | [Town Wins]
Replies: 3681
Views: 140129

Re: Episode X | Day 9 | Xplore your Options

Very unlikely Nelly is mafia. And that has nothing to do with how I read her.
by VucubCaquix
Fri Jul 01, 2016 7:08 pm
 
Forum: Game Threads
Topic: Episode X | A Comedy of Errors | [Town Wins]
Replies: 3681
Views: 140129

Re: Episode X | Day 9 | Xplore your Options

Hippo can't be scum unless someone misread one of their messages.

They framed hippo to make it look like the investigation results could have been tampered with. And why not, not like anyone else was being investigated. They could've sent the blackmailer at hippo and it would've been the same result.
by VucubCaquix
Fri Jul 01, 2016 6:35 pm
 
Forum: Game Threads
Topic: Episode X | A Comedy of Errors | [Town Wins]
Replies: 3681
Views: 140129

Re: Episode X | Day 9 | Xplore your Options

First point I touched on in an earlier post. Chubby's wording was especially weird around this part, and it sets him apart from other people who were initially against a mass claim.

Second point is that Chubby contradicted his earlier viewpoint completely. I don't see how you could write this off completely but I guess we're all a little tired

Third point is pretty simple. Since the mafia had 3 confirmed scum already who weren't the godfather, they wouldn't have a reason to frame Hippo as anything but Cit/GF. It would be especially pointless with a spy, since we would recognize framer as a possibility.

Its different with Chubby, since Chubby is not in the Cit/GF pool. If Chubby is town, then they just let a veteran be confirmed for some reason. Why do that?
by VucubCaquix
Fri Jul 01, 2016 6:13 pm
 
Forum: Game Threads
Topic: Episode X | A Comedy of Errors | [Town Wins]
Replies: 3681
Views: 140129

Re: Episode X | Night 7 | Xecuted Immediately

Swordsworth wrote:
ChubbyMooshroom9 wrote:Slept peacefully.

Pretty sure CMITC is scum fl that quick hammer.

/vote CMITC


Doesn't support your theory. Neasans also forgot Caporegime cannot roll.


Are you really using a statement from DAY 7 to try and explain why Chubby isn't buddies with Cmit? CMIT WAS CONFIRMED SCUM BY DAY 7. THIS ONLY MAKES HIM LOOK WORSE!

Also as the master of townslip detecting I will tell you that that is not a townslip by Loch Nes. Moving on.

I'm not feeling like doing all the quoting I need to do for an ISO, so debate me on these points.

1. If Chubby is town, that means the framer didn't visit him on night 6. Why would the framer refrain from doing this? We told Retral upfront to investigate Chubby.
2. If Chubby is town, why did the mafia kill Alzar before Retral? They could have prevented Chubby from being confirmed at all, giving them a bigger chance of winning.
3. Chubby was against a mass claim after the bomber fused. Why?
4. Chubby has continually pushed against easily scum readable townies all game, such as Downie, Jord, Murat. He also goes after Elusive a lot.
5. On day 3, Chubby stated:

ChubbyMooshroom9 wrote:Why would Mafia help Town? Right now, mafia want to try to whittle Town's numbers(by manipulating Santa via Witch) down while we chase after Bomber Suspects. Pretty much, if we cannot lynch correctly(scum) in the first to days, Mafia/scum has achieved a pretty much guaranteed win. Once they lynch the Bomber, it will be over if we mislynch twice,and then incorrectly witch. Not to mention Mafia usually king-make Neutral roles over Town roles.


On day 4, Chubby doubts Downie can be town at all based on the evidence given by a blackmailer. His attitude change is amazing, see for yourself.
by VucubCaquix
Fri Jul 01, 2016 5:21 pm
 
Forum: Game Threads
Topic: Episode X | A Comedy of Errors | [Town Wins]
Replies: 3681
Views: 140129

Re: Episode X | Day 9 | Xplore your Options

I haven't yet. Will get to it, if you give me the chance.
by VucubCaquix
Fri Jul 01, 2016 4:46 pm
 
Forum: Game Threads
Topic: Episode X | A Comedy of Errors | [Town Wins]
Replies: 3681
Views: 140129

Re: Episode X | Day 9 | Xplore your Options

Don't be nervous. Hippo is confirmed town. Let's party?
by VucubCaquix
Fri Jul 01, 2016 4:37 pm
 
Forum: Game Threads
Topic: Episode X | A Comedy of Errors | [Town Wins]
Replies: 3681
Views: 140129

Re: Episode X | Day 9 | Xplore your Options

Salense...

I've slept peacefully all game.
by VucubCaquix
Fri Jul 01, 2016 4:30 pm
 
Forum: Game Threads
Topic: Episode X | A Comedy of Errors | [Town Wins]
Replies: 3681
Views: 140129

Re: Episode X | Day 9 | Xplore your Options

Neato.

Pretty sure your all wrong and Chubby is the last mafia. Here's why.

1. On night 6, Alzar was killed. A strange choice, considering an investigator was still alive, as well as an escort. Why would they do this? The spy was practically useless.
2. Chubby was chosen as investigation target the night before Chubby was investigated by Retral. The mafia knew this was going to happen.
3. Known framer NC was not roleblocked during night 6, as TC was roleblocked that night. Meaning a framer was free to do whatever he wanted that night.
4. The framer must have visited Chubby that night. There just isn't any way they wouldn't send the framer towards Chubby. Why wouldn't they take advantage of this and frame Chubby as Cit/GF? The only reason I can think of is that Chubby was actually the godfather.

This explains the weird kill order as well as NC's medium claims. I want to look into his ISO but I think this is correct.
by VucubCaquix
Fri Jul 01, 2016 4:13 pm
 
Forum: Game Threads
Topic: Episode X | A Comedy of Errors | [Town Wins]
Replies: 3681
Views: 140129

Re: Episode X | Day 6 | [insert X pun here]

Jfc nelly what are you even doing. If he's town your practically confirmed scum.
by VucubCaquix
Sun Jun 26, 2016 12:19 pm
 
Forum: Game Threads
Topic: Episode X | A Comedy of Errors | [Town Wins]
Replies: 3681
Views: 140129

Re: Episode X | Day 6 | [insert X pun here]

Congratulations, nobody has accomplished anything. Lynch tiem
by VucubCaquix
Sun Jun 26, 2016 12:15 pm
 
Forum: Game Threads
Topic: Episode X | A Comedy of Errors | [Town Wins]
Replies: 3681
Views: 140129

Re: Episode X | Day 6 | [insert X pun here]

Just end the day. We win either way, so there's no point arguing over it.
by VucubCaquix
Sun Jun 26, 2016 10:57 am
 
Forum: Game Threads
Topic: Episode X | A Comedy of Errors | [Town Wins]
Replies: 3681
Views: 140129

Re: Episode X | Day 6 | [insert X pun here]

1. We aren't lynching NCYT, because NC can still be town. End of story. That should be cleared up tonight, so we don't have to worry. No taking risks.
2. Where was our roleblock last night? Should've been on NC again. If it wasn't we have a problem.
3. No broadcasting who Murat blocks. As I recall, any mafia can make the kill, so telling Murat what to do is counterproductive. Unless its to block the framer, which is pointless now.
4. Nelly's night plan is.... :/

Murat roleblock:

25% cmit
25% NC
50% Between Hippo, TC, and Chubby. Use judgement.

We have a small chance of blocking it.
by VucubCaquix
Sat Jun 25, 2016 7:34 pm
 
Forum: Game Threads
Topic: Episode X | A Comedy of Errors | [Town Wins]
Replies: 3681
Views: 140129

Re: Episode X | Day 6 | [insert X pun here]

/vote evildeanius

Leave roleblocking decision to murat, since Retral going to die anyways prob. Got a 20% chance or so to prevent a kill.

Cmit was framed

There are some possibilities here but its not worth doing anything about yet.
by VucubCaquix
Sat Jun 25, 2016 3:53 pm
 
Forum: Game Threads
Topic: Episode X | A Comedy of Errors | [Town Wins]
Replies: 3681
Views: 140129

Re: Episode X | Day 5 | Xmas is Cancelled

Nvm I lost my train of thought. Go ahead.
by VucubCaquix
Thu Jun 23, 2016 9:52 am
 
Forum: Game Threads
Topic: Episode X | A Comedy of Errors | [Town Wins]
Replies: 3681
Views: 140129
Next

Return to: Episode X | A Comedy of Errors | [Town Wins]