Town of Salem Game Forums

There was a lot of questionable plays this game, but it was interesting regardless

I find it funny I was killed as the TP because I knew about the Marhsal information from another game at the time that I was marshal in

Good to know that I can play the part of Citizen though since that is what I was going for.

Town was off to a good start too, the lynch on Mel was strange considering the Marshal claim and dead Sheriff but C'est la vie regardless. Still interesting at least, definitely questionable plays to start with to learn from.

Whom are we missing?

/Vote Kotkowski

RIP Kot

Harkonnen97 wrote:The blackmailer told him that, you mean. Yeah, that is a plausible theory. However, why would the Mafia attack ObiWan3 when he was basically a Citizen? Why not attack someone else for the chance to kill the TP?

Uncertainty in the plan, you don't know if you're right about the mafia nor if they were going with the plan so may as well take out someone whom would be a threat if left alone

So yes we should start getting votes in

My current theory is that mafia could have
Mafioso
Consigliere
Blackmailer

Consig found the Vigilante, and with how Kot was acting took the gamble that he was witch, as they would know he was not mafia so anonymously told him who the vigilante it to control instead.

I'm more than certain the witch controlled Obi, the shot on Swords doesn't make sense to have done it on their own when there were clearly scummier targets to go after.

That would be obnoxiously over powered with mafia able to kill so many per night

jakob12341 wrote:You didn't forget that there are 2 members of the mafia left right? One of them attacked the vigilante and the other one but we don't know what the other one did and I don't think Kot was talking about the witch but the other mafia tell me if I'm saying something wrong here mafia tactics makes all the mafia being like the Mafioso by giving up their role for the night if I'm correct there's a chance that the other one went for me but the "Marshal" got there first (this was just a thought)

Only one mafia is allowed to attack per night, even with tactical in play. Only one is allowed to sacrifice their ability to attack

Jakob definitely needs to be the one investigated by the sheriff next, we need to know for sure if we are dealing with a consort or escort once that is handled we can progress from there, That should be the Sheriff's main priority target for now

With that said after we see Kots flip, I already covered what would happen from there I believe. Right now everything is speculation and we don't have much to go on, unless we're expecting some major scum slip from someone that wont be seen as new player mistakes then we should be able to go ahead and vote.

It would be good for Desta to be investigated next if we are lynching Kot and they flip Witch. I really don't see them flipping Marshal at this point so Desta can be a next choice to be checked out. After that we'll go from there

That's actually a good point as far as the Consort is concerned, however it can be quickly resolved dependent on how Kot flips at this point.

If he flips mafia, the point becomes moot as no other mafia will remain so no mafia buddy to claim roleblocked and if the target assigned is not role blocked and mafia kills or no mafia kills and they are roleblocked then we will have more leads to go on

If he flips witch, Austin can then investigate the escort to tell one way or the other. Whomever here is the town protective can protect them so we can get affirmative results regardless

If he flips town, we're back at square one with even less to go on and mafia will have a leg up on us unless we can prevent the night kill through block or protect.

Macca would make for a choice to RB, they don't seem to be a good read on anyone's table so far regardless

Has Kot come back to explain their claim yet?

The push for reveal actually helped quite a bit as it was questionable response and the logic needs to be explained so that it makes sense

We do still have the Town Prot alive I am sure at this point, getting rid of witch would be the best bet. Escort will have to listen to town on whom to role block now or be seen as Consort while sheriff continues to find the rest of the mafia.

If they are witch we should handle them immediately to prevent them messing with what we need done

The doctor heals from all attacks, however mafia killed Vigilante and Vigilante killed Citizen. There would be nothing to protect from as the Doctor with our role list, same goes for BodyGuard.

Being new, I spent enough time looking and re-reading all the roles for purposes like this
A marshal will not know if they scare of someone without killing intentions.

We still have time to discuss though, shouldn't hammer too quickly so we can see to other claims and comments.

kotkowski wrote:It's rlly so hard?
Somebody visited jacob as I've protected him


Better?

Are you claiming he was attacked then? Mafia killed the Vigilante, you cant possibly know of another visit unless you claim RT lookout in which you don't know if they are evil or now but the protected claim says otherwise.

Explain

Witch is the NE in this game which does exist, clearly

Kot, as a townie and the position we are in concerning mylo you should be very against being lynched as it would end things for the town. That does come off as very suspicious in the end by voting yourself on the stipulation Trusty is not to be trusted if you flip town.

P-Edit, the first seems unlikely there Hark so I would agree in that they are scum. Acting this way in no way benefits town...

I kinda forgot about Desta to be honest, between them and Kot I would consider it

To keep conversation going, should we go for Kot instead? If the Escort is in fact correct we don't want to risk mislynching them. Seeing on how the night goes after this will be telling enough about how to handle it next go.

I noticed, seems everyone is in different time zones which does make this rather interesting and amusing to say the least

Now them, clearly Desta and Kot are top picks as potential scum, interestingly enough I could see DorkofPork flipping as our residential Witch.

Pork has been playing relatively pulled back and not too active in the town, but not necessarily scummy either. Kinda taking a neutral stance offering bits and pieces here but the consistency in saying" I am not mafia" or "If I were mafia" and other like statements avoids saying I am part of the town as well. It wouldn't surprise me to see them flip witch.